Board 8 > Elden Ring Mafia Topic 7: Consecratered Snowfield

(+) Yeah! (+)

MZero made it look like he had a scan for the first 12+ hours of the day, though.

I didn't believe the dayvig claim, though. I actually thought he was still just a scanner.

I feel like a whole lotta votes have been flung around since we last had votals done.

Give me a moment.

Isquen posted... Ooog... I think I just realized something, then.

##unvote
##vote:Shonen-Bat

Back in a few hours.

While I'm counting, did we ever get what this "realization" was before he quickly jumped back onto me?

Most were to test the freezer

Anyways, despite me bullying Chris earlier , I could see Sultan slotting in with Panth and Corrik.

I'll probably make a full reads list here shortly.

Message ratings:
[7]Good: Ben, chang, Chris, Ulti, Panthera, Marth, Isquen

Votes:
[3]Corrik: Chris, Ben, IGCD
[2]Panth: Isquen, Marth
[1]Shonen: Ulti, (Isquen), (Isquen)
[1]Chang: Corrik
[1]Isquen: (Ulti), Sultan
[0]Chris: [Marth]
[0]Crescent: (Isquen), (Isquen)
[0]Sbell(DEAD): (Mzero), (chang), (Chris), (Panthera)

Unofficial votals as of the end of topic 6. Topic 7 to come.

UnderUrMattress posted...

Most were to test the freezer

Anyways, despite me bullying Chris earlier , I could see Sultan slotting in with Panth and Corrik.

I'll probably make a full reads list here shortly.

This is exactly why we need updated votals, because we just had a random spray of crap.

More importantly, how many good votes do I have?

..... alright I'll probably have to count those myself.

Oh never mind you got them

Good evening (or bad evening I guess since y'all want to kill me). I'm just a boring old vanilla. My attention is split with other stuff tonight so I just don't have the mental energy for more than a few thoughts and maybe answering a few short questions tonight, but there's something I've been thinking on that I want to actually go into proper detail about and I'm going to be sure to do it tomorrow. This time I will be certain I'm here with plenty of time to go before deadline I promise and I have nothing else scheduled so you can get full effort Panthera for a few hours.

While I'm here why is anyone even bringing up Red again, SBell clearly slipped that they poisoned him. With Ben basically confirmed third party Red is as close to confirmed town as you get without being confirmed. You'd have to assume him as an additional independent to get any other conclusion.

And one more thing since I want to at least get this out in case you guys lynch me while I'm asleep or busy.

UnderUrMattress posted...

Yeah I've convinced myself that Panth is scum and want them to claim asap pronto.

##Vote: Marth

As said before his actions tend to underwhelm, but this really seals it to me. Marth voted me seven hours prior to this. Was coaxing at Chris to try to join him on it. Now says he's finally convinced himself I'm scum. Maybe he wanted the claim earlier moreso than being sure of my alignment, but then if he's convinced now, why ask for the claim? You don't need a claim from someone you're convinced is scum, you need claims from people you're still not fully sure about. He's not truly thinking about this from a scum hunting perspective, just emulating it with scum hunting phrases that don't quite add up.

I'll try to pop in a bit more tonight, if not hope to chat with you folks tomorrow.

Bad night then, panthera

I mean I'm not the only one that wanted you to claim lol.

I feel like you're trying to go after me because everyone else you've tried to go after, you've failed to get.

Panthera posted...

While I'm here why is anyone even bringing up Red again, SBell clearly slipped that they poisoned him. With Ben basically confirmed third party Red is as close to confirmed town as you get without being confirmed. You'd have to assume him as an additional independent to get any other conclusion.

I had a theory that didn't make sense.

Message ratings:
[7]Good: Ben, chang, Chris, Ulti, Panthera, Marth, Isquen

Votes:

[4]Panth: (Isquen), Marth, (Chris), (Chang), Ben, Chris, (IGCD), Isquen
[3]Shonen: Ulti, (Isquen), (Isquen), MZero, Sultan
[1]Ulti: Corrik
[0]Chang: (Corrik)
[0]Isquen: (Ulti), (Sultan)
[0]Corrik: (Chris), (Ben), (IGCD)
[0]Chris: (Marth)
[0]Crescent: (Isquen), (Isquen), (Isquen)
[0]Sbell(DEAD): (Mzero), (chang), (Chris), (Panthera)

Not voting: Bat, Chang, Crescent, Panthera, Red

Why is this adding up to 13 people who am I missing I've been on this for minutes now.

Unofficial present votals.

Is Isquen is aiming for the record for most votes on a single person who isn't voted for anyone else?

Will IGCD vote and unvote someone 10 times to claim his dominance?

STAY TUNED.

Panthera posted...

Good evening (or bad evening I guess since y'all want to kill me). I'm just a boring old vanilla. My attention is split with other stuff tonight so I just don't have the mental energy for more than a few thoughts and maybe answering a few short questions tonight, but there's something I've been thinking on that I want to actually go into proper detail about and I'm going to be sure to do it tomorrow. This time I will be certain I'm here with plenty of time to go before deadline I promise and I have nothing else scheduled so you can get full effort Panthera for a few hours.

While I'm here why is anyone even bringing up Red again, SBell clearly slipped that they poisoned him. With Ben basically confirmed third party Red is as close to confirmed town as you get without being confirmed. You'd have to assume him as an additional independent to get any other conclusion.

And one more thing since I want to at least get this out in case you guys lynch me while I'm asleep or busy.

##Vote: Marth

As said before his actions tend to underwhelm, but this really seals it to me. Marth voted me seven hours prior to this. Was coaxing at Chris to try to join him on it. Now says he's finally convinced himself I'm scum. Maybe he wanted the claim earlier moreso than being sure of my alignment, but then if he's convinced now, why ask for the claim? You don't need a claim from someone you're convinced is scum, you need claims from people you're still not fully sure about. He's not truly thinking about this from a scum hunting perspective, just emulating it with scum hunting phrases that don't quite add up.

I'll try to pop in a bit more tonight, if not hope to chat with you folks tomorrow.

...Flavor?

PunishedBen posted...

Oh never mind you got them

The last votals had them and the only additional one was right after those last votals, so it was pretty easy.

UnderUrMattress posted...

I feel like you're trying to go after me because everyone else you've tried to go after, you've failed to get.

Scum taunting.

Crescent-Moon posted...

Is Isquen is aiming for the record for most votes on a single person who isn't voted for anyone else?

##Unvote
##Vote: Crescent
##Unvote
##Vote: Marth

Rude.

This push on me is so bad lmao. The crux of it is I asked him to claim when I scumread him. Why wouldn't I ask for your claim? Being confirmation biased is bad. If I proceeded to tunnel you without getting some kind of information, how would that help me?

I feel like the scum team is boxed in and they're trying to take shots at people in the POE (yours truly).

IfGodCouldDie posted...

I had a theory that didn't make sense.

Ladies and gentlemen of this supposed mafia game.... This, is Chewbacca.

Why would I be talking about Chewbacca in a mafia game?

I don't know, it doesn't make sense!

If Chewbacca does not make sense, you must acquit.

Crescent-Moon posted...

Ladies and gentlemen of this supposed mafia game.... This, is Chewbacca.

Crescent-Moon posted...

Why would I be talking about Chewbacca in a mafia game?

I don't know, it doesn't make sense!

If Chewbacca does not make sense, you must acquit.

Not sure what the point of trying to be a passive aggressive asshole is.

Bit you do you I guess.

UnderUrMattress posted...

I feel like the scum team is boxed in and they're trying to take shots at people in the POE (yours truly).

It feels a bit this way, but I've learned better than to put a lot of stock into that feeling.

I was trying to be humorous about it, not antagonistic.

Crescent-Moon posted...

I was trying to be humorous about it, not antagonistic.

Ok. I can forgive and forget if thats the case. Sorry I took it the wrong way.

Panthera posted...

Scum taunting.

Scum taunting?

Maybe we should look at your voting history then.

Votes:
[2] Ben: (Panth), (Chris), Sbell, Ulti, (Chris), (Death), (IGCD), (Sultan)
[1] Isquen: (Crescent), (Ben), (IGCD), (Ulti), Panth
[0] Chang: (Panthera), (Ulti), (Ulti)
[0] Red: (IGCD), (Panthera), (Sultan)

You tried to get Ben (who is decidably not scum out), Red (literally poisoned), chang (bodyguard claim), and Isquen (probably just town) out.

None of those worked out for you and now your next best option is me.

Your votes have been so calculated all game bro.

Much like my attempts to be funny in person, it totally missed the mark.

It's probably related to where I am on the spectrum.

Panthera's first two votes were pretty quick. They've slowed since then. Though that's the second straight vote that came in wall form.

I'm going to look up his vote on Red because I've been against a Red lynch pretty well all game.

Crescent-Moon posted...

I'm going to look up his vote on Red because I've been against a Red lynch pretty well all game.

iirc he retracted that one really quickly so that one doesn't carry much credence

the one that bothered me the most was his vote on chang 100% but the other two were pretty bad as well.

Panthera voted Red because Red wasn't answering him on his mindset before claiming.

Panthera's vote on Chang was for "being noncommittal", which was rather quickly debunked by Chang apparently being the same way in FE.

And good lord, Corrik's vote on me on T1 P4 was trash. Sultan votes on Corrik shortly after with what's essentially a demand to stop being a dick and actually play the game.

I'm inclined to believe scum Sultan/town Corrik is not viable based on this. If scum Sultan had the bells to step up to town Corrik like this I'd be legitimately surprised.

Crescent-Moon posted...

Panthera voted Red because Red wasn't answering him on his mindset before claiming.

Panthera's vote on Chang was for "being noncommittal", which was rather quickly debunked by Chang apparently being the same way in FE.

And good lord, Corrik's vote on me on T1 P4 was trash. Sultan votes on Corrik shortly after with what's essentially a demand to stop being a dick and actually play the game.

I'm inclined to believe scum Sultan/town Corrik is not viable based on this. If scum Sultan had the bells to step up to town Corrik like this I'd be legitimately surprised.

i'm currently operating on a tinfoil that i pressured sultan into a read when i called him out initially and he bussed corrik. he felt confident in the read, but i didn't agree with anything he said at all, and it felt like he knew too much.

sultan's been towny on tone though.

and i do kinda like that sultan's reads have been in contrast with the general game state from time to time.

UnderUrMattress posted...

i'm currently operating on a tinfoil that i pressured sultan into a read when i called him out initially and he bussed corrik. he felt confident in the read, but i didn't agree with anything he said at all, and it felt like he knew too much.

sultan's been towny on tone though.

Sultan didn't really call him scum, it was more "If you're town, stop being a dick".

Crescent-Moon posted...

Sultan didn't really call him scum, it was more "If you're town, stop being a dick".

i did ask sultan for his top scumread for him to get into the game in case he had a rough start as a townie

he said it was corrik and the read felt overly confident, i can point out examples.

UnderUrMattress posted...

i did ask sultan for his top scumread for him to get into the game in case he had a rough start as a townie

he said it was corrik and the read felt overly confident, i can point out examples.

Oh I just looked at the vote, which was post 203.

When did he call Corrik a scumread?

Sultan calls Corrik a scumread almost immediately following Corrik's vote on me, which then leads into Sultan's vote.

Sultan also calls me a townread in the same post he calls Corrik a scumread, no less.

Which also plays into what I've already said: For Sultan to be scum, he's been actively buddying up to me.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...
Catch up here after dinner to immediately find that Corrik's vote on Crescent-Moon is lacking something to it. I would like corrik to maybe go more into his thoughts. Corrik litterally stating everyone always finds him to be scummy. If I remember correctly corrik likes to throw that out when he is scum then brags when he comes back as scumm if he wins. But regardless of that.

I've been feeling good about moon at the moment she seems to be playing conservatively while actively looking.

As for Red and pant im not sure what to think

TheSultanOfSlam posted...
Corrik also dropped a vote bomb put no effort into his vote then leaves.

Not to mention the

This is what makes me worried like very confident in a day 2 for himself

And saying everyone always thinks I'm scummy anyways. Its not a good look to me.

Corrik isn't actively playing its not beneficial

##vote:corrik <--- this vote was official but i have no idea how to properly quote on this website so i don't want it to go on my record

if you're town corrik you need to stop holding your grudge and give us more other then what you're giving. Give an actual reason to vote moon and maybe you wouldn't look bad to me youve only posted a handful of times and none of them were anything

I think the bolded was a HUUUUUUUUUUUGE reach. This whole vote and push was really bad.

tl;dr chris is still the goat and i was a moron for questioning him even slightly

I still question him.

You know that's never going to stop constant vigilance and all that.

wait but seriously do you think what i'm saying holds any value or am i stretching too hard here

UnderUrMattress posted...

He also buddied Panthera

in fairness Corrik buddied Panthera last game and Panth wasn't even on the playerlist

UnderUrMattress posted...

wait but seriously do you think what i'm saying holds any value or am i stretching too hard here

Thinking.

Crescent-Moon posted...

Which also plays into what I've already said: For Sultan to be scum, he's been actively buddying up to me.

I don't think this is extremely unlikely.

You were fairly universally townread besides a few people that decided to ruin your groove.

It wouldn't be uncharacteristic at all for a mafia member to buddy up to someone of that nature, especially once they've claimed they're unlynchable.

But I will give you that Sultan has been really towny at points in this game, and he's probably not someone I'll push on for some time now, just pointing out a few concerns is all.

MZero posted...

in fairness Corrik buddied Panthera last game and Panth wasn't even on the playerlist

????

UnderUrMattress posted...

I don't think this is extremely unlikely.

You were fairly universally townread besides a few people that decided to ruin your groove.

It wouldn't be uncharacteristic at all for a mafia member to buddy up to someone of that nature, especially once they've claimed they're unlynchable.

But I will give you that Sultan has been really towny at points in this game, and he's probably not someone I'll push on for some time now, just pointing out a few concerns is all.

I was not "fairly universally townread" on topic 1 page 4, though, and this was long before I claimed.

But on that note I was a little bit weary of how hard Ben came in to say lynching me was off the table.

I'm so fucking pumped. Let's gooooo