Board 8 > Elden Ring Mafia Topic 7: Consecratered Snowfield

(+) Yeah! (+)

How about Panthera and igcd claim. First one to claim doesn't die. It's the sbell special

I fully support that

Panth also claimed vanilla in one of his walls

But he didn't claim flavor. I don't respect it

Maybe it was like an igcd joke. People joke these days

jokes used to be funnier back in my day

Also if panthera is vanilla why did he move last night

lol

Sorry sheep I wanted you to have time for a little adventure but as soon as he claimed this day was over

Space Moose - Observer

I'm a boss that was revealed during a demo or trailer. (I think there is more flavour text but I'm trying to do this off of memory.)

I am given the number of actions attempted at night. Thats why I was wondering about there being a N0 because when I asked for clarification on my ability I found out my powers activate on N1. There were 9 actions attempted last night. I only observe actions attempted, so passive actions do not count and whether or not they were successful has no bearing on whether or not observe them.

aw man you could have gotten another scan off, he's dead to rights already and poisoner might be replacing strongman

I got some adventure time in it's all okay regardless

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Space Moose - Observer

I'm a boss that was revealed during a demo or trailer. (I think there is more flavour text but I'm trying to do this off of memory.)

I am given the number of actions attempted at night. Thats why I was wondering about there being a N0 because when I asked for clarification on my ability I found out my powers activate on N1. There were 9 actions attempted last night. I only observe actions attempted, so passive actions do not count and whether or not they were successful has no bearing on whether or not observe them.

Do your own actions count?

No.

That sounds an awful lot like my role. Are you the third party? I notice you didnt say TOWN observer

I don't take action. My role is considered passive.

PunishedBen posted...

That sounds an awful lot like my role. Are you the third party? I notice you didnt say TOWN observer

I'm town.

IGCD's role is so easy to confirm whether he's town or not, I wonder if it can even be town

It does kind of sound more useful practically for scum than it does for town to have

But regardless if that even is his real scum role than he is the LAST person we kill because that role is harmless

That number feels slightly off to me. Assuming Isquen, Crescent, and MZero are all town, which feels pretty safe, all of the unclaimed have to be power roles, unless Red is lying and is actually power. I kinda agree that it sounds more useful for scum? But I feel like roleblocker/poisoner/godfather equivalent is a fairly safe bet for the remaining team and the first two are practically guaranteed already. Maybe in a five man scum team.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Ill try to save face here and answer those questions..

What changed about Marth is that your stances seem to be a bit non commital today compared to yesterday. Like I said I do want to go back and look. Just my quick skim today something seems a bit different

You actually feel this way? If anything, my D1 was super non-committal, but I feel like I have way more conviction with my pushes today. I felt really unsure and nervous about myself on D1 cause I haven't played with this board in awhile, and I haven't played with it much at all. What really ignited my fire was MZero vigging SBell which showed me that I was on the right track on D1 which motivated me to build from where I left off at. I do feel that I've made it clear that unless Panth's play improves, he is who I want to have lynched. I have waffled a bit on you and Corrik, but I thoroughly explained why I felt differently about you guys than I did earlier in the day.

PunishedBen posted...

That sounds an awful lot like my role. Are you the third party? I notice you didnt say TOWN observer

PunishedBen posted...

IGCD's role is so easy to confirm whether he's town or not, I wonder if it can even be town

PunishedBen posted...

It does kind of sound more useful practically for scum than it does for town to have

PunishedBen posted...

But regardless if that even is his real scum role than he is the LAST person we kill because that role is harmless

The fuck?

IfGodCouldDie posted...

The fuck?

Its all good, I agreed the first one to claim doesn't die. Just speculating

Yeah we're good on IGCD for a while. Lots of ways to outplay that role if it is scum (or if it's scum just pulling a number out of thin air), and it's a very easy claim to confirm later in the game.

##Unvote

PunishedBen posted...

Its all good, I agreed the first one to claim doesn't die. Just speculating

Just a really unnatural thought progression in such a short time.

I followed the thought progression fine there.

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Just a really unnatural thought progression in such a short time.

My thought progression was - That doesnt sound like a town role .... but I wouldnt touch it until the end of the game after everyone has claimed since it can be provable by then

I don't love that claim but eh. Let's just stay the course with Panth and if for whatever reason that's a miss, then we worry.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

I followed the thought progression fine there.

Oh I followed it but it feels like someone that has wanted to call me scum all game finely having the opportunity to take me out of their town reads list, more than it felt like someone that had me on their town list changing their mind on me due to the claim.

I mean Ben is a nefarious third party so you are right to worry

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Oh I followed it but it feels like someone that has wanted to call me scum all game finely having the opportunity to take me out of their town reads list, more than it felt like someone that had me on their town list changing their mind on me due to the claim.

Haha. You dont realize how much I want you to be town though. I want nothing more than after the game to be able to quote my post where Chris said to state my town reads and then said they were shitty and to have them all be accurate! IIRC, you were on that list.

...Sbell was too, but as a joke. I hope i made that clear in the post or that would look embarrassing.

If there's any paranoia its deciding which of my town reads I'm wrong about. Because even if Panth and Corrik are both scum, there is a third scum and a third party remaining somewhere.

It's okay. I like the third party

Message ratings:
[7]Good: Ben, chang, Chris, Ulti, Panthera, Marth, Isquen

Votes:

[4]Panth: (Isquen), Marth, (Chris), (Chang), Ben, Chris, (IGCD), Isquen
[1]Sheep: Ulti, (Isquen), (Isquen), (MZero), (Sultan)
[1]Ulti: Corrik
[1]Marth: Panth
[0]IGCD: (Ulti), (Sultan), Sheep
[0]Chang: (Corrik)
[0]Isquen: (Ulti), (Sultan)
[0]Corrik: (Chris), (Ben), (IGCD)
[0]Chris: (Marth)
[0]Crescent: (Isquen), (Isquen), (Isquen), (Panth)

As a reminder I am just pulling from the previous unofficial votals. It is up to players to make sure they are correct. If they are wrong and not caught at the end of the day then 'oh well'

By the way, the only reason I know there is a third party is because I was only given that information night 1 as well. Its why I didn't think anything of Sultan and Chang's posts talking about one on day 1.

And I need more good ratings than that. If I can get all good ratings maybe we unlock the secret ending or something! I'm only begging so hard because I know there's town holding out on me and its the wrong move. We're all on the same team here. Not sure what I have to do to to convince you, but i will have a MUCH easier job doing so if I get better rewards tonight. More ratings = better rewards

oh yeah ##Rate: Good

why does Ben always get the weird roles

9 actions

scum kill death
scum poison red
sbell vote freeze chris
me protect chris
Ben write message
+
chris watch panthera (if Im assuming that from your post?)
+
doctor heal ???
scum RB ???
+
one mystery action

Sheep007 posted...

oh yeah ##Rate: Good

why does Ben always get the weird roles

I was thinking the same thing.

or i think its not watch but called motion detect in this? If thats right

Keep in mind my abilities may count as two separate actions last night. I dont even know for sure myself, but it seems that way.

changmas posted...

9 actions

scum kill death
scum poison red
sbell vote freeze chris
me protect chris
Ben write message
+
chris watch panthera (if Im assuming that from your post?)
+
doctor heal ???
scum RB ???
+
one mystery action

I don't want to speculate too much about this rn

PunishedBen posted...

Keep in mind my abilities may count as two separate actions last night. I dont even know for sure myself, but it seems that way.

How many of your actions do you physically have to submit to Plum?

IfGodCouldDie posted...

How many of your actions do you physically have to submit to Plum?

Also, im sure you could ask for clarification on that as well.

Last night, two

I had the ability to write a message
And the ability to put out the Instill into the world.

Either of which I could have chosen not to. I;m not gonna ask him anything like "If IGCD's role is real, would these count as 2 moves?" because I dont feel comfortable with those kids of questions. Better question is, does YOUR role PM give any indication whether its just how many players moved, or how many actions were taken?

PunishedBen posted...

Last night, two

I had the ability to write a message
And the ability to put out the Instill into the world.

Either of which I could have chosen not to. I;m not gonna ask him anything like "If IGCD's role is real, would these count as 2 moves?" because I dont feel comfortable with those kids of questions. Better question is, does YOUR role PM give any indication whether its just how many players moved, or how many actions were taken?

I've already explained that in my claim.

There were 9 actions attempted last night. I only observe actions attempted, so passive actions do not count and whether or not they were successful has no bearing on whether or not observe them.

Also you don't ask, "if gods role was real." You just ask if your actions are considered passive or if they count as actions attempted.

Between you claiming my role sounds like yours and you being unwilling to actually try and sort this out, I am losing faith in keeping you around as a good idea.

UnderUrMattress posted...

I don't want to speculate too much about this rn

booooooring

I'm more than willing to sort it out. If I'm giving you a hard time its because pressuring someone is in the spirit of sorting them out.

My actions are not passive. That I dont need host clarification on anyway. Passive would be like a 1-shot bulletproof.