Board 8 > Simple Mafia Topic 3: Simple captions for standard games

(+) Yeah! (+)

Obellisk posted...

well presumably the gamenwould be over

But its not unless it's a scum win. Which it shouldn't be if it is 1 and not 2

Sultan you want plum lynched your gunna need to show me why plumsquen is scum and why igcd is absolutely not.

Kirby can be left out of this since it's clear no one is lynching him.

You yourself though isquen was very scummy before replace.. plum came in and attacked Ulti wh already had some traction on it. Looking at isquen in topic 1 he does not have many pro town posts.

His votes exspecshally the one on IGCD was abysmal.

Ill look to find my other points against plum I had a few just notnsure how to put them into words to exsplain it but
I have court for work all day so waiting time I should be able to look into it

As for igcd like I said before his rebuttals to my weak attacks on him seem pretty legit for him.

Plus he is the only one thinking outside the box and that is pretty solidly town IGCD and probably why he is considered one of the most improved town players.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

You yourself though isquen was very scummy before replace

can you show me where I said this? because I don't believe I joined the push to lynch him.

Obellisk posted...

can you show me where I said this? because I don't believe I joined the push to lynch him.

The one post i thought was yours was Peafs after going back to look. But either way go look at Isquen topic one it pretty bad. Actually while you're at it read peafs thoughts they are pretty good.

But you did have a post where you basically shook your head at Isquen and kept going back to arguing with me soo there is that

PunishedBen posted...

Peaf really wanted to kill Isquen. But I also doubt Isquen would be leading a scum team.

But Ben was and killed peaf this is kind of funny plus kind of protecting Isquen

I should have listened to my topic 2 self more about Ben tbh...

My problem this game may have been thinking way to much about things, I usually take a much more simple approach

I'll be back a little later this evening when I hope we can end this day and possibly win this game for town.

Just sitting down to a very heavy day at the office and like i said i'm going away tomorrow so lots of clean-up.

Sultan, keep posting.

Plum, IGCD, Kirby, final thoughts or potential secondaries.

Cheers everyone.

Don't have much to add. Sultans self vote than immediate unvote feels disingenuous after Ulti already killed himself as town. I feel pretty confident it is Sultan but I've been way more confidant and way more wrong

I think scum sbell would probably let town Sultan implode here so we might be over thinking this. It's most likely Sultan and if it isn't Sultan it's going to be IGCD. I'm getting to the point where I'm ready to lynch those two and if you or Kirby fooled me I'll be blown away and respect you a lot more next game.

Weird thing i am having trouble looking past for IGCD is that Vote on the uncounter claimed Cop. That might be one if the worst votes I've ever seen...

My poe turned into IGCD or Plum ive done alot of that plum digging. I can do IGCD when I am done. But we just saw IGCD scum game.

Id also like to hear more from him and his argument against Plum to see if we are actually on the same page

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

##vote:Sbell

beentrying to set me up as mislynch

Ill be gone for a bit dont lose until I get back okay?

Like I just don't see a universe where Town Sultan comes in with this immediate vote that could lose the game if there are 3 scum (I believe this was before I laid out why that was unlikely and I don't know if he would have thought that through at that point)

And then does a complete 180 and lands on

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

My poe turned into IGCD or Plum

Yeah, lets go. It's Sultan

##Vote:Sultan

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

My poe turned into IGCD or Plum ive done alot of that plum digging.

I just don't buy this. I don't buy you came in at a potential lylo and fired off a vote immediately then decided "Oh, I guess I should do some research now that it looks like I am going to die"

And why would Plum digging lead you to IGCD over Sbell?

Aw, I was hoping the self-vote would stick so I could bring it to -1 and see which impatient guy would dare risk the hammer.

Given that Sultan is more than eager to self-vote himself, I will refrain from voting him right in case he decides to hammer himself and isn't scum la Ulti.

I'd like to hear more from IGCD before we end the day, though. I liked his thoughts from earlier in the day, but I think a bit more spotlight on him would do well. I think Sbell's has posted plenty of good content, and Plum isn't even on my table for lynching. So I just want to make sure that, if the game keeps going, we're absolutely sure who the remaining scum is.

There really isn't much to add. After the Sultan flip my PoE would be Plum and unless he is the one killed i can't see either you or Sbell as scum. I feel fairly confident this is a wrap.

If we've all said our share.

then let's just wrap it up

Kirby makes no sense.

I'm ok with plum

igcd looks better than Sultan.

a win would be great

a loss won't count with how absurd this whole thing is.

I'm ready.

Also, want to reiterate I pointed out sultans first post as a clear scum not sure how to start the game post.

So let's hope that's right.

Kirby, would you like the honor?

Well, gentlemen, let's end this.

##Vote: Sultan

Congrats in being wrong guys.

@BlueCrystalTear

Stop

I'm out and about and won't be home until tonight so no flavor.

Sultan has been lynched. He was Vanilla Town.

Get night actions to me if you have them ASAP, thanks. Round may start tonight (later than normal, probably) or tomorrow depending. Thanks for your patience and understanding!

I got home safe. And so did all of you, because no one died.

SEE BELOW FOR IMPORTANT LYLO REMINDER BEFORE YOU VOTE

The alive:

1. IGCD
2. Plum
3. Kirby
4. SBell

My fellow ghosties:
[KN1] Peaf Town Vanilla
[SD2] Ulti Town Vanilla
[KN2] Corrik Town Cop
[LD3] Ben Mafia Goon
[KN3] ctes Town Vanilla
[LD4] Sultan Town Vanilla

Today is MYLO. If you lynch someone who isn't scum, the game is over.

This also means that once you vote, that's it, it's final. NO UNVOTING IS ALLOWED. I thus suggest you hold your vote until you've gotten all the information you need.

Good luck to all.

Lylo rule is lame because I want to vote no lynch but my guess is that isnt going to gain traction and its just going to be awkward with a frozen vote on no lynch

Going to do a full reread of Sbell before Im committal but I dont think much has changed other than I am super confused what was going through sultans head. I still dont understand that Sbell vote of his.

So continuing to be as little simple as possible mafia...

lovely.

scum can eat a butt for no killing here.

Wait a sec.

This isnt lylo this is Mylo

2-2 tie with frozen votes doesnt work

Sultan you were extremely unlike your usual Sultan self. I would say for certain you really let your win streak get to your head and then when it got you into trouble your attempt to fix it just came across as insincere. Sorry.

masterplum posted...

This isnt lylo this is Mylo

2-2 tie with frozen votes doesnt work

A 2-2 tie would result in a randomized lynch from the two tied parties.

And you are correct. It is MYLO, not LYLO. My bad. I'm still green enough at this. I have amended the above post. Votes are still locked right now.

We will save the rules discussion for after the game. Carry on.

I honestly wouldn't be opposed to a No Lynch. If scum wants to play lame, so can we.

... But then scum could just continue to No Kill for every time we No Lynch, and I doubt stalling out the game would be appreciated by the spectators and the host. Ugh.

I'm still thinking Plum is town, unless he's really upped his game from the last times. That leaves IGCD and Sbell. IGCD is the easy answer, but I think I should do an actual reread to see what connections Ben has made to everyone, or lack thereof.

So by rule of thumb now kirby and plum are confirmed town for being spoken directly to in game?

Just did a re read of isquen and still didn't feel like lynching him when everyone else did. So bully for you plum

And Kirby, while I'd love to no lynch it and play a long game of chicken, I agree we should end this game. I am gone tomorrow morning.

Kirby321 posted...

... But then scum could just continue to No Kill for every time we No Lynch, and I doubt stalling out the game would be appreciated by the spectators and the host. Ugh.

After asking dead town to see if anyone has had such an experience (I've never seen anything like that), if you all stall for 3 days and 3 nights, the game will end in a stalemate with no winner.

I'd like to petition dead town chat for a 4th day.

BlueCrystalTear posted...

After asking dead town to see if anyone has had such an experience (I've never seen anything like that), if you all stall for 3 days and 3 nights, the game will end in a stalemate with no winner.

... Well, I'm tempted to go for a No Contest just to spite Ulti since he wanted us to lose so badly lol

masterplum posted...

Lylo rule is lame because I want to vote no lynch but my guess is that isnt going to gain traction and its just going to be awkward with a frozen vote on no lynch

Going to do a full reread of Sbell before Im committal but I dont think much has changed other than I am super confused what was going through sultans head. I still dont understand that Sbell vote of his.

I am 100% willing to draw by forcing scum to kill.

And just to prove it.

##Vote: No Lynch

if all think I'm scum let's end the game.

I will say this much, the no kill really leads me to believe it is Kirby, because if it was Sbell or Plum they easily mislynch me to win the game. I know this also make me look bad because of fear they auto lynch me which is why I am down to stalemate just so scum doesn't win.

I want to hear what you think of the no lynch plan Sbell

And by that I mean the no lynch enough to draw

So this is my thought pattern on the situation right now.

ScumPlum has no reason to leave Kirby alive.
ScumBell has no reason to leave Kirby alive.
ScumGod maybe leaves Kirby alive because he hopes that three people that have been wishywashy on him all game decide to vote differently
ScumKirby can't kill himself.

IfGodCouldDie posted...

So this is my thought pattern on the situation right now.

ScumPlum has no reason to leave Kirby alive.
ScumBell has no reason to leave Kirby alive.
ScumGod maybe leaves Kirby alive because he hopes that three people that have been wishywashy on him all game decide to vote differently
ScumKirby can't kill himself.

Where are you going with this?

I mean if we all choose no lynch we are essentially saying this game should be a no contest game, should end and we should all pretend it didn't exist.

Is that what we want instead of giving either faction the satisfaction?

corriks rolling over in dead town chat right now

Yeah I'm not gonna comment on any of that. I'd rather not discuss scum's nightkill for them :P

They wanna play lame to win the game? As if. Scum should do their own work and make their own mistakes, not have us work out everything for them. We don't benefit at all from discussing the possibilities if Person A dies or if Person B lives and such until scum commits to a kill. Otherwise, we're working out all of the best situations for them to just pick and choose from for their own benefit.

Scum already have the upper hand here. We need to agree to No Lynch and force scum's hand, because the numbers are unfavorable for us right now. Until they bring it to LyLo, we have no reason to discuss anything imo, especially when all of us who are left are Vanillas.