Board 8 > Community Mafia Topic 2 - The Psychology of Fake Claiming

(+) Yeah! (+)

Isquen posted...

Yes, how dare I go to bed when I'm low-key sick, exhausted and not wanting to catch up beyond "Kirby randomly voting me for ??? reason."

Cool, that's the reaction I was expecting. Isquen is town.

##Unvote

Forceful_Dragon posted...

I look forward to getting a similar level of activity from you discussing other players as well.

Pot, meet kettle

Kirby321 posted...

Cool, that's the reaction I was expecting. Isquen is town.

##Unvote

That feels like a premature townread
He's not lying yes (I presume), but in the end thats just all a nultell.

Apologies for the lack Votals today while I interview for a new job as DEI-n of a new college Votals
[2] Kirby - Peaf, (Ulti), Sbell
[2] Wallz - Ben, (Ulti), Corrik
[1] Sbell - (Lopen), (Taco), Blade, (Taco), (Red)
[1] Blade - (Sbell), Lopen
[1] Knightz - (Taco), Taco, (Ulti)
[1] Taco - Knightz
[1] Chang - (Peaf), Ulti
[1] FD - (Ulti), Red
[0] Red - (FD)
[0] Isquen - (Kirby)
[0] Lopen - (Kirby)
[0] Death - (Taco), (Ulti)
[0] MI - (IGCD), (Knightz)

With 19 alive, it takes 10 to lynch. Day ends May 1st at 6 PM EST.

wallmasterz posted...

Pot, meet kettle

Absolutely ridiculous to compare me and red in that.

I was actively reading and posting for hours before red "returned even though he never left". And until that point he had done literally nothing but throw a vote at Sbell, call an Ulti list bad and say hi to MI.

Are these the kind of illogical conflations we can expect from you this game, wallz?

Not to make FD mad again. But as a fellow D&Der, I understood what Red was saying.
Mostly.
Him wanting to vote Sbell I can see as being a confusing element of that readback post.

htaeD posted...

But as a fellow D&Der, I understood what Red was saying.

But as a fellow human being could you also understand what it looked like red was saying?

Especially when it followed it up by actually not really being around, so the context of his actions only reinforced what it seemed like he was saying.

Thanks, Lea!

Of the players with votes, i think wallz is the towniest.

Anyway, Kirby - if you're going to base your entire read of Blade off of what other players think, i suggest you prod wallz and igcd because they were on his team and had more of a front row seat to the whole ordeal than i did. I was furiously tunneled in on lopen for 110% of the game so i only really evaluated Blade's play in hindsight.

Oh your reaction is pretty understandable.
I just think Red probably was playing D&D

I dont think he lies to excuse his inactivity, I didnt get any of that from our last scumgame at least.

Fd - i did not understand what red was saying. I agree with your assessment of the timeline.

I do not agree that it's relevant to anything other than him being argumentative.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Assuming that was a serious job interview update, good luck host! And sorry I was mean to Lopen, but I feel he deserves it for reasons outside mafia that I shouldnt have brought in here. Thats on me.

In other news.

##Unvote
##Vote: Knight

Its very dirty meta to explain why, but hes confirmed scum now.

I claimed town, if you can give me your "very dirty meta" maybe I'll loosen my firm belief that you're scum.

PeaceFrog posted...

I do not agree that it's relevant to anything other than him being argumentative.

The relevant part was his immediate reaction being to counter vote me for "not paying attention" when it was my attention that caused me to notice him in the first place.

But I digress, that's enough about red, for now

Ulti you really should learn to share meta

Forceful_Dragon posted...

Absolutely ridiculous to compare me and red in that.



Are these the kind of illogical conflations we can expect from you this game, wallz?

You have posted more than red so far, yes. Thats to be expected since red said he was playing d&d. I dont think youve done anything else since falling down the semantics rabbit hole. You want red to post about the game more, my point is you should endeavor to do the same.

Tho Knightz, you must realize that it is alarming to see anyone say they 'claimed' town instead of saying they 'are' town.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Your chances of getting me mislynched are 0%. Mainly because I want scum wasting night actions on me night 1

wait, you said mislynched not lynched which means you're scum.

Forceful_Dragon posted...

The relevant part was his immediate reaction being to counter vote me for "not paying attention" when it was my attention that caused me to notice him in the first place.

But I digress, that's enough about red, for now

Okay I dont believe you have that limited an understanding of the word ''attention" and all of its applications.

TotallyNotMI posted...

I want to go back to this with Taco suddenly saying Kirby might be third party.

I haven't played Among Us in some time, but when I did there were certainly no third parties.

Did third parties get added to Among Us?

I thought every game had third party. :( I was sorta kinda keepingtrack of the last game and saw that Sid was third party and thought every game had them. Well kirby is scum.

No, mislynched means lynched to town's detriment.

htaeD posted...

Ulti you really should learn to share meta

That defeats the purpose! And it's bad form imo.

htaeD posted...

Okay I dont believe you have that limited an understanding of the word ''attention" and all of its applications.

By all means, educate me. I've already explained what I understood him to be saying I'm excruciating detail.

Scum (Probably):
Knightz
Kirby
Ulti?

Tacocraft545 posted...

Well kirby is scum.

This is the same attitude that got IGCD dayvigved in toy story mafia

Forceful_Dragon posted...

By all means, educate me. I've already explained what I understood him to be saying I'm excruciating detail.

No I get that.
I dont think Red means that you werent paying attention to him when he was around or not.
But that you werent paying attention to why he was not around or not.

ItzKnightz posted...

This is the same attitude that got IGCD dayvigved in toy story mafia

And that was a bad thing?

ItzKnightz posted...

This is the same attitude that got IGCD dayvigved in toy story mafia

IGCD was scum. Godfather in fact.

##Vote: Ulti

This is 100% Ulti roleplaying our perception of what town Ulti is and Flanderizing himself in the process

But you all keep avoiding voting him cause you can't read him and you don't want him to throw a hissy fit

I'm getting pinged by a lot of the same things Ulti is seeing with Taco/Knightz. I don't want to believe both could have rolled scum because man that just feels lazy but both of them have posted things that feel like slipping and/or having too much information for a new player.

Tacocraft545 posted...

I thought every game had third party. :( I was sorta kinda keepingtrack of the last game and saw that Sid was third party and thought every game had them. Well kirby is scum.

Even this feels like someone on the scum board told Taco to say this to try to deflect how he knew about third party

UltimaterializerX posted...

Ill answer you, Death.

I dont think this blatant fake claim matches the wording in anyone elses role PM. You get me? It reads like a Discord copy-paste.

And I think you would know this since you once got caught on similar logic (using the wrong html tags).

Actually I was town then (I was just on a lot of other forums that dont have Gamefaqs weirdass bold/italic styles)
Also that was like a decade ago.

Tacocraft545 posted...

I thought every game had third party. :( I was sorta kinda keepingtrack of the last game and saw that Sid was third party and thought every game had them. Well kirby is scum.

No actually this was the answer I expected since I think he did mention reading the last game.

Must be thinking of a different game then. But I maintain I have never been caught as scum for wrong tags.
Primarily.

hrm
I also thought that maybe Knightz told him about the SK from last game beforehand. But Knightz seems to find it odd that Taco mentioned SK as well.

I am only making things harder for future scum me

UltimaterializerX posted...

but I feel he deserves it for reasons outside mafia that I shouldnt have brought in here

More evidence Ulti is paired with Blade btw

Why is he thinking of bad stuff I did outside mafia (??? What did I even do?)

Btw bold of topic 3 to assume we are getting around to the b8 special in that topic.

Lopen posted...

More evidence Ulti is paired with Blade btw

Why is he thinking of bad stuff I did outside mafia (??? What did I even do?)

I dont know and frankly it shouldn't have been brought up here.
Not sure why this ties him to Blade tho, but I also dont know if that question can even be answered while I am standing by my first sentence.

UltimaterializerX posted...

I saw that topic title! Its like she knows something >_>

The true pain of Bloodborne Mafia was not knowing when to quote Gehrmans dying quote in the topic title

Blade dislikes me openly and is exactly the type of player to vent about me in scumchat when I didn't play along with him trying to harness me for evil (and frankly, pregame)

Stands to reason Ulti is paired with at least one player that dislikes me