Board 8 > A Feast For Crows Mafia: Topic 1 - Some Men Think Because They're Afraid To Do

(+) Yeah! (+)

how is that in fairness, you roll mafia assassin and read that your shot cannot fail in any circumstance and you think to yourself well my sot cannot fail no matter what because that is what this role does and what the role text says it does I mean come on
---

Admittedly not having all the information Boko sounds like he's in the right here

Right but if it had stated it worked like it actually did mechanically (ie my clones no selling it being the only exception to it) nothing changes. I still beat you. You needed the shot to work better than intended, not for the text to be modified.

Look we can argue over the ancient game where I played 10/10 after the game. I know you are likely tired and HAPPY from the party, but notice anything before nappy nap?
---

I stand by my wording, since your shot didn't fail. And what you targeted did in fact die.

It just wasn't what you thought you targeted.
---

Vengeful_KBM posted...

Admittedly not having all the information Boko sounds like he's in the right here

I was a 1 man scum team who had a night action where my clone would take any action meant for me at night if I used it.

Including any sort of kill.

FFD balanced this around protecting me from all deaths.

So basically FFD should have somehow worded assassin differently for Boko, but it was balanced not to work so!
---

Also my "should" should have been in quotes, because yeah it totally died!
---

OK so the setup itself was ridiculous and not meant to be taken seriously. Check :p

Stargate Mafia was a beautiful 24 man game and I love it.
---

This game is super sidetracked right now.

it was from a different era of mafia
---

Says the Eeveelution who so far has discussed modkills (which annoys me), described FFD's personality and attributed a random alignment to it (???), and now informs us that the game is sidetracked without offering anything to unsidetrack it.

Next thing you know you will be telling me I talk too much and need to 'shh' and go to bed.
---

FFDragon posted...

it was from a different era of mafia

Hey, me too!

^5

I mean, I did still ask a question of red that has gone unanswered.
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Stargate Mafia was a beautiful 24 man game and I love it.

I wish I were here for that one.
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Says the Eeveelution who so far has discussed modkills (which annoys me), described FFD's personality and attributed a random alignment to it (???), and now informs us that the game is sidetracked without offering anything to unsidetrack it.

Next thing you know you will be telling me I talk too much and need to 'shh' and go to bed.

I've been here like 3 minutes total.

And its not so much FFD's personality as him thinking he'd be a tough lynch in this game. Think he'd go down easy if this player base wanted to.

FFDragon posted...

I mean, I did still ask a question of red that has gone unanswered.

I assumed that wasn't a real question.

He is by my account on my level of skill as a player, I don't find it out of place for him to call himself a tough lynch. I think of myself the same way.
---

what is it with everyone thinking i'm just mashing keys for my own amusement this game
---

Current Votals
[1] Jeff: Nana
[1] dowolf: Chris
[1] MI: Puns
[1] Chris: (Puns), Scare
[0] Nana: (Chris)


With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch (early). Day ends Monday at 9 PM CST (roughly 43.5 hours from now).
---

FFDragon posted...

what is it with everyone thinking i'm just mashing keys for my own amusement this game

Hey now.
---

mostly* everyone
---

You asked a dumb question, i ignored it assuming you were being sarcastic.

Excuse me for overestimating your intelligence.

Oh I just realized I am going to be terribly drunk for deadline. Oops.
---

it would be a dumb question if I played the game, sure

but it was brought up independently, and coupled with the fact that you seem to be sad(?) (angry?) that you have apparently rolled town this time as well, I want to know why you think you were lynched as town

if your play was at fault or it was just from circumstance

why is everyone so instantly hostile

the only way for information to be gathered is for us to you, you know, interact with each other

just answer questions is it so damn hard
---

If it makes you feel better I have genuinely missed you and consider it nice to play with you again, even if it turns out I have to dismember you.
---

In case I am asleep and aren't around when this fills up, please use this topic when this one hits 450.

https://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/75445380
---

MysteriousStan posted...

ScareChan posted...

KBM, Nana, Stan are my top 3 "Going to be up for lynch anyways" group

I'm curious, please elaborate, Scare.

Any reason why you ask me and not VI when we basically said the same thing?
---

It does feel good to play again, yes.

It just feels like no one wants to commit themselves to an opinion right now, even for the simplest of questions.
---

I'm committed to the opinion that I just watched an average episode of Babylon 5.
---

You can ask me anything you want bud, I'll answer. No promises on honestly though, in case I need to be sneaky.
---

I think you'd be disappointed in me if I trusted you at this point anyway.
---

I don't know, it's kind of a fine line. Like yeah I expect proper paranoia and diligence but after years of Spiral trying to shove me into a box every game sometimes it is nice to be given the benefit of the doubt if only for a change of pace.
---

*attempts to shove Chris into a box*

Vengeful_KBM posted...

*attempts to shove Chris into a box*

This seems scummy.

<_<
---

KBM this reminds me while I am more affable than I used to be, you can feel free to start providing some content about the game and its inhabitants whenever you feel comfortable.

Cough.
---

I mean, I don't distrust you either. I'm just saying don't misconstrue friendliness for trust. Do find it weird that people just keep popping up to needle you.
---

Okay.

You seem pretty genuine, which lol doesn't tell me anything.

Nana, as I said, came off really disingenuous - I just reread that section and I can't see it as anything but posturing. Between this comment:

Nanahara715 posted...

Standing out to me is the "only going to ask questions if confident", which seems like a precursoring excuse for not being active.

the "dick pissing" comment, to the random dismissive one-sentence remarks laced in between, I am just really having a hard time reading any of it as someone trying to be helpful. Nana, if your play "speaks for itself" it is not speaking particularly highly right now.

Meanwhile that FFD/Red interaction just now was weird. Was "Have we met before?" somehow supposed to be a legitimate question? That back and forth kind of lost me.

Any more specific things you'd like to hear my opinions on?

Yeah I know. Also I am kind of a mythical creature at this point. Ah, here's something you wouldn't have known: after you and many other 'legends' quit I kind of took over board 8 mafia on a skill and experience level, and really helped improve a lot of players, sometimes in not so nice ways, but improvement. So I am kind of a mythical creature at this point.
---

Do you think Dowolf forgot he was supposed to claim town when he quoted a note from me saying scum wouldn't draw my eyes on them and he said 'your move'
---

Although I would argue you haven't provided that much of substance either, just talking yourself up a lot. Which, again, doesn't strike me as out of the ordinary. No tell there.

Vengeful_KBM posted...

Was "Have we met before?" somehow supposed to be a legitimate question?

smug and self-referential could be the subtitle of my autobiography

I asked that (sarcastically) because red was saying it like it was some sort of revelation


.......wait, which means that when red was asking if my question was serious he was probably refering to that.

god dammit does no one read the topic either
---

Dowolf popping up with that MSPaint job and then disappearing is a little odd, but you can't expect me to take your vote seriously.

Vengeful_KBM posted...

Although I would argue you haven't provided that much of substance either, just talking yourself up a lot. Which, again, doesn't strike me as out of the ordinary. No tell there.

- Called MI and puns town
- noted suspicion of nana and dowolf
- prompted red and now you to provide more to go the game

I would counter argue ;x
---

Yeah because perspective slips are never a thing!
---

I can't see where anybody would get a read on MI yet, unless the two of you have some secret code.

Or is this one of those things where it's like "he NEVER just casually sits around and chats with people on the first two pages if he's scum"? Genuinely curious here.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Nah, I got called 'scummy' and someone said 'This is a terrible idea.' These people are using logic or something.

Actually that may make MI town too since puns was the other person to comment on my obvious joke. I can imagine very uptight MI being like "Chris that isn't a good idea!" as town reflexively.

---

I'll just go ahead and say that FFD and I are so winning the "reads posts in the game" award so far.
---

^5
---

Oh don't lie now and accuse me of not reading the game. Just because I didn't understand his one-sentence comment that didn't even look like it was serious about a game that I didn't read.

I mean you did just ask me how someone could think MI is town when I had a post explaining why I thought MI was town.
---