Board 8 > Chris' Music Mafia Topic 12: Bohemian Rhapsody

(+) Yeah! (+)

Yes this also explains why Panth died. Panth is smart. He would have targeted Tony like we all wanted him to
---

Current Votals (Last vote #66)

[4] - Scare - Sheep, FD, Zach, Tange, (Puns)
[2] - MZero- Death, Scare

with 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch. Day ends 10:00 PM EDT Thursday.

---

turbopuns2 posted...

Crescent-Moon posted...

Wouldn't this theory also work in tandem with what I've been saying not to trust innocent scans, then?

well sure. when I asked why specifically do you think there's a godfather, I specifically didn't say "well if they have a ninja they just shoot sheep without a care" and then the scene is just flip flopped and tony is left alive so "they must have a ninja?"

but I didn't want to attract scum to the fact I was thinking that way. but whatever, now the information is out there and I can die in peace if that should come to pass.

Personally seeing "unscannable" just made me think scum had another role that messed with scans, godfather just made the most sense.

benjamin3740 posted...

Yes this also explains why Panth died. Panth is smart. He would have targeted Tony like we all wanted him to

This is a pretty good point.

This scum board is going to be pretty fun to read if it was Tony counter claiming Zam that set him off.
---

and tony with like the most weak-willed day 1 watcher counter of all time

Edumey was not ninja, so he definetivly didn't roleblock night 1. That's all I need to

##Vote: Tony :P
---

benjamin3740 posted...

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Edumey was roleblocker and Tony claimed roleblocked night 1. We know Eaed covered Corrik.

So isn't Tony basically confirmed scum on that alone? Holy craaaap

Someone answer this because I might be remembering history wrong. But Puns said Edumey didn't move night 1. Tony claimed roleblocked the first two nights

I was blocked the first three nights, actually.

Alright whatever. But that includes the first night. Why would scum roleblocker EVER take no action if not to pretend a block on his own scum team?

I feel like if I were scum in that situation I'd want my roleblocker to act anyway.

So either scum has some super manipulation role or Tony is scum

Which could make for an interesting question in itself, then. Was "unscannable" actually godfather ninja?

*Wakes up*

wha?
---

I guess we can hope Scare is a scum mastermind or something so this shit gets put to bed tbh.
---

Crescent-Moon posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Edumey was roleblocker and Tony claimed roleblocked night 1. We know Eaed covered Corrik.

So isn't Tony basically confirmed scum on that alone? Holy craaaap

Someone answer this because I might be remembering history wrong. But Puns said Edumey didn't move night 1. Tony claimed roleblocked the first two nights

I was blocked the first three nights, actually.

Alright whatever. But that includes the first night. Why would scum roleblocker EVER take no action if not to pretend a block on his own scum team?

I feel like if I were scum in that situation I'd want my roleblocker to act anyway.

So either scum has some super manipulation role or Tony is scum

Which could make for an interesting question in itself, then. Was "unscannable" actually godfather ninja?

If he were to act then there would be two people claiming blocked. That''s a problem and an immediate reason to suspect Tony, who is meant to be in it for the long haul after countering his own scum. Of course there WERE two peopke claiming blocked, but they didnt know about jailer. Also this explains both Sultan and Tony getting blocked. Maybe it was not Eaed after all
---

Cant Barb use a whip? Thats reason enough to get it tbh
---

am I the only vanilal in the game

this is boosheet
---

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

Cant Barb use a whip? Thats reason enough to get it tbh

Flailing!

Jk
---

turbopuns2 posted...

and tony with like the most weak-willed day 1 watcher counter of all time

Tony did half ass the counterclaim initially, but not a lot of other people responded before then.

I think part of the problem might be that its such a stupid gamble on a vacuum to risk two scum like that day 1. It also basically requires other scum to stay alive because Tony would be autolynched at end game for never dying.

But if you think about it, Red, Leo, and Scare, with a "confirmed" Tony, made for a pretty powerful core. We just murdered two of them with fake scans.

Its certainly possible they thought it would work.

Oh, well then
Too tired to type much now. I believe this will suffice.

##Unvote
##Vote: Tony
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Crescent-Moon posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Edumey was roleblocker and Tony claimed roleblocked night 1. We know Eaed covered Corrik.

So isn't Tony basically confirmed scum on that alone? Holy craaaap

Someone answer this because I might be remembering history wrong. But Puns said Edumey didn't move night 1. Tony claimed roleblocked the first two nights

I was blocked the first three nights, actually.

Alright whatever. But that includes the first night. Why would scum roleblocker EVER take no action if not to pretend a block on his own scum team?

I feel like if I were scum in that situation I'd want my roleblocker to act anyway.

So either scum has some super manipulation role or Tony is scum

Which could make for an interesting question in itself, then. Was "unscannable" actually godfather ninja?

If he were to act then there would be two people claiming blocked. That''s a problem and an immediate reason to suspect Tony, who is meant to be in it for the long haul after countering his own scum. Of course there WERE two peopke claiming blocked, but they didnt know about jailer. Also this explains both Sultan and Tony getting blocked. Maybe it was not Eaed after all

We just had a game that had a double roleblocker in it, and Jack can carry a roleblock. It wouldn't have been a damning suspicion.

puns why did you say that you meta'd chris into me being scum jack
---

Blocking Sultan and blaming Eaed for it is possible. I made it clear on day 4 I didn't believe Eaed blocked Sultan.

Crescent-Moon posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Crescent-Moon posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Edumey was roleblocker and Tony claimed roleblocked night 1. We know Eaed covered Corrik.

So isn't Tony basically confirmed scum on that alone? Holy craaaap

Someone answer this because I might be remembering history wrong. But Puns said Edumey didn't move night 1. Tony claimed roleblocked the first two nights

I was blocked the first three nights, actually.

Alright whatever. But that includes the first night. Why would scum roleblocker EVER take no action if not to pretend a block on his own scum team?

I feel like if I were scum in that situation I'd want my roleblocker to act anyway.

So either scum has some super manipulation role or Tony is scum

Which could make for an interesting question in itself, then. Was "unscannable" actually godfather ninja?

If he were to act then there would be two people claiming blocked. That''s a problem and an immediate reason to suspect Tony, who is meant to be in it for the long haul after countering his own scum. Of course there WERE two peopke claiming blocked, but they didnt know about jailer. Also this explains both Sultan and Tony getting blocked. Maybe it was not Eaed after all

We just had a game that had a double roleblocker in it, and Jack can carry a roleblock. It wouldn't have been a damning suspicion.

Say he could doublerole block. He didn't. He didn't move. That still needs explained to me. The only possible scenario is that Puns is lying completely
---

I almost just modkilled myself on accident by deleting that post meant for the FFBE topic lol.

Anyway, im not concerned about this, with alllllll this Town power theres undeniably a powerful scum role out there that will solve this.

...And if it IS Puns, somehow, then well played homie.
---

It's funny that Scare is both the person to suggest both watcher claims were scum and that scum might've had some way to know the game didn't have one.

That would be super amusing if Scare just told us the truth.

Not to mention, tracker + watcher + cop is too much.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Say he could doublerole block. He didn't. He didn't move. That still needs explained to me. The only possible scenario is that Puns is lying completely

The previous double RBer (me) couldnt use the power two nights in a row
---

And to people lynching Tony right now, we should still be lynching Scare first.

Puns tracks Tony, Tony watches Puns. Sheep does whatever he wants.

There just simply isn't a role that explains Puns seeing Dumey not taking an action night 1. It has to be what really happened. Dumey was not ninja. One of Puns'random tracks that night was correct (sultan on Panth), so there was nothing interferring with his scan results directly
---

also sorta explains Puns' willingness to not lynch Edumey
---

htaeD posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Say he could doublerole block. He didn't. He didn't move. That still needs explained to me. The only possible scenario is that Puns is lying completely

The previous double RBer (me) couldnt use the power two nights in a row

Yeah and if he couldnt move night 1, then Tony lied about being roleblocked night 1.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

There just simply isn't a role that explains Puns seeing Dumey not taking an action night 1. It has to be what really happened. Dumey was not ninja. One of Puns'random tracks that night was correct (sultan on Panth), so there was nothing interferring with his scan results directly

The only other option is scum has a role that can change the scanning properties of other scum, yes.

Pursuit ~ Wanting to Find the Truth

Crescent-Moon posted...

And to people lynching Tony right now, we should still be lynching Scare first.

Puns tracks Tony, Tony watches Puns. Sheep does whatever he wants.

I agree. I just wanted to vote so people took me seriously
---

Crescent-Moon posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

There just simply isn't a role that explains Puns seeing Dumey not taking an action night 1. It has to be what really happened. Dumey was not ninja. One of Puns'random tracks that night was correct (sultan on Panth), so there was nothing interferring with his scan results directly

The only other option is scum has a role that can change the scanning properties of other scum, yes.

Unscannable that targets others to make THEM unscannable?
Hmm nah, EDumey wouldnt be so mad that sheep didnt scan red then.
Now with 3 targets for scum to hit, I doubt tony will be effective (willingly or not)
---

also unscannable I dont think would come up in the watch result so thats another thing that Tony may have goofed
---

Oh and since I've claimed now I'm fine with being on the MZero list if you all wish to confirm me

htaeD posted...

Not to mention, tracker + watcher + cop is too much.

Watcher
Tracker
Cop
Bodyguard
Elite Bodyguard
Doctor/blocker/Mason
Target Bomb Scanner
Jailkeeper

And Scum got

Detective
Vanilla
Unscanneable
Roleblocker
---

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

htaeD posted...

Not to mention, tracker + watcher + cop is too much.

Watcher
Tracker
Cop
Bodyguard
Elite Bodyguard
Doctor/blocker/Mason
Target Bomb Scanner
Jailkeeper

And Scum got

Detective
Vanilla
Unscanneable
Roleblocker

dont forget the vig

This makes me almost buy scare
---

ScareChan posted...

also unscannable I dont think would come up in the watch result so thats another thing that Tony may have goofed

That never sat right with me
---

so this is my understanding of Miz' role

at night he submits a list of potential scum

for every correct answer he gets is given a shorter list of people to blow up on and it does that by removing a member of town from the equation

is that a simple but correct answer
---

I totally agree on the lynching Scare first front. Just get one likely scum out of the way. The Puns/Tony situation can be cleared up tomorrow and if Scare is scum we've basic won, and whichever of those two is scum may as well forfeit.
---

ScareChan posted...

also unscannable I dont think would come up in the watch result so thats another thing that Tony may have goofed

If I was scum Id know what unscanneable was, you think Id have said I watched him? Ouch, hurts youd think so little of me.

Anyway, I really like how ben is literally just repeating Puns point over and over lol
---

ScareChan posted...

so this is my understanding of Miz' role

at night he submits a list of potential scum

for every correct answer he gets is given a shorter list of people to blow up on and it does that by removing a member of town from the equation

is that a simple but correct answer

yes
also the list can have as many players as there are scum left
---

Tony exactly what was your watch result
---

ScareChan posted...

so this is my understanding of Miz' role

at night he submits a list of potential scum

for every correct answer he gets is given a shorter list of people to blow up on and it does that by removing a member of town from the equation

is that a simple but correct answer

Yes. And he only gets to submit a list the size of the remaiming scum
---

and I am not done with last topic yet but what is it that made puns feel I baited him? that tony is probably why panth died?
---

ScareChan posted...

so this is my understanding of Miz' role

at night he submits a list of potential scum

for every correct answer he gets is given a shorter list of people to blow up on and it does that by removing a member of town from the equation

is that a simple but correct answer

I think so
---

ScareChan posted...

Tony exactly what was your watch result

Sultan and red targeted sheep last night.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Crescent-Moon posted...

And to people lynching Tony right now, we should still be lynching Scare first.

Puns tracks Tony, Tony watches Puns. Sheep does whatever he wants.

I agree. I just wanted to vote so people took me seriously

Meow.

ChaosTonyV4 posted...

ScareChan posted...

also unscannable I dont think would come up in the watch result so thats another thing that Tony may have goofed

If I was scum Id know what unscanneable was, you think Id have said I watched him? Ouch, hurts youd think so little of me.

Anyway, I really like how ben is literally just repeating Puns point over and over lol

I don't think he mentioned the Dumey contradiction. But he bolded Dumey's name so I assume he knows about it. Puns did you never consider Tony scum before today?
---

Can Miz not talk in twilight?
---

Crescent-Moon posted...

And to people lynching Tony right now, we should still be lynching Scare first.