Board 8 > Monster Mafia: The Rebootening Topic 4 - Clowns

(+) Yeah! (+)

Forceful_Dragon posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

When you ask questions, often times you will get an answer.

Yeah I asked questions too and was told that those answers were not relevant to me.

Wait you asked about how Chris' role works? How/why?
---

Forceful_Dragon posted...

I spoke about chris
I spoke about the chris/plum situations and how I felt that it was going to resolve itself with plum's lynch

I have believed in miller masons since day 1.
But I don't like it when everyone changes their claims every 30 minutes to suit their particular whim.

I haven't been keeping a master list of all claims like I normally do. In part because of laziness, but in part because it sucks being vanilla when everyone else has crazy shit.

I said that i've felt people have been laying the groundwork for my mislynch, but I already said my feelings on that.

I have not developed any new feelings on those issues since the last time I've said something regarding them.

I do have a new feeling, which is one of being upset that you are making me feel as though I have not been pulling my weight, when I do not think that is the case.

Am I supposed to repeat myself every 6 hours on things where my feelings and opinions have stayed the same?

And it's been a long day so i'm going to sleep now. If you are curious what my thoughts are before I wake up, feel free to read something I've already said. Unless I have some really trippy mafia dreams it will still be an accurate representation of my thoughts.

If this is what you thought, then why when Plum asked us to lynch Chris when he flipped town did you say "No Deal" ???
---

I do want a mass claim
---

Not a good time for that just yet, I don't think.
---

best time
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

best time

Have you claimed?
---

Actually, I have a theory and mass claim might just solve the game.

Quick list of claims:

Sheep007 - Cult Leader, no role claimed
Leafeon13N
MZero11

DoomTheGyarados - Sam(?) Winchester, Prosty who doesn't alert who they scan and can't do n2
ScareChan - (Flavor?) Mason, but not Miller
benjamin3740 - (Flavor?) Mason, but not Miller

HanOfTheNekos - Member of Brotherhood of Cthuhlu, vanilla
Obellisk - Ash, vanilla
Forceful_Dragon - some witches, vanilla

##Unvote:
---

Obellisk posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

best time

Have you claimed?

yes.
---

I'm Van Hesling. Scare is Richter Belmont. Both hunting Dracula
---

Han says he's a member of the Cuthulu cult.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

DoomTheGyarados - Sam(?) Winchester, Prosty who doesn't alert who they scan and can't do n2

BTW, this sentence alone should be enough for you to lynch him.
---

Chris might be scum due to rule 1 but I'd rather not invoke Rule 1 when FD is obviously scum. If someone else dies tonight then we can start looking at rule 1ing Chris
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Han says he's a member of the Cuthulu cult.

I'll make a note of that on my updated claim list.

Sheep007 - Cult Leader, no role claimed
Leafeon13N
MZero11

DoomTheGyarados - Sam(?) Winchester, Prosty who doesn't alert who they scan and can't do n2
ScareChan - Richter Belmont, Mason, but not Miller
benjamin3740 - Van Hesling (sic), Mason, but not Miller

HanOfTheNekos - Member of Brotherhood of Cthuhlu, vanilla
Obellisk - Ash Williams, vanilla
Forceful_Dragon - some witches, vanilla
---

ok I'm dumb. You know how I said I don't pay attention to flavor.

Well, I just went and actually read my flavor.

My flavor specifically mentions hunting witches.

I think FD claimed his real flavor as scum.
---

Forceful_Dragon posted...

For the record this is the "first message" that mzero has said i'm scum for:

Forceful_Dragon posted...

Frivolous First Message

This was the first time (in memory) I'd been around when the first day went up. I wanted to make a frivolous first message, as often seems to be maid at the beginning of day 1. But I wasn't sure what to say so i just said 'frivolous first message'. Apparently that is alignment damning now?

If you kill me, I hope MZero is properly ashamed of himself for using this as the initial basis of his justification for thinking I'm scum. Because this is where he decided I was scum and he has seemed to try to fit all the other pieces together to support that initial determination. It's flawed thinking, and in this case particularly it has reached the wrong conclusion. So sad to be wrong based on such a flimsy thing.

It's not alignnent damning, but it's a building block. Since then you've continued to post in a way that doesn't attempt to solve the game but rather just make you look active, just like your first post.

Thanks for calling me town though!

Also it would be interesting if FD and Chris are both scum and that's why FD was so insistent on getting credit for lynching him but we can cross that bridge later
---

red13n posted...

ok I'm dumb. You know how I said I don't pay attention to flavor.

Well, I just went and actually read my flavor.

My flavor specifically mentions hunting witches.

I think FD claimed his real flavor as scum.

LMAO

After reading this I did the same thing and got the same result

Well except I supposedly defend humans from witches but basicallh the same
---

Main reason I don't want a mass Claim is because I don't really suspect all the people yet to reveal roles. (Sheep, Han, Red, Mzero). But if you have insight to how it'll solve the game then I'll be more for it
---

red13n posted...

ok I'm dumb. You know how I said I don't pay attention to flavor.

Well, I just went and actually read my flavor.

My flavor specifically mentions hunting witches.

I think FD claimed his real flavor as scum.

yes looking for dracula is mentioned in our flavor

and I think that red doesnt go out of his way to make this up as scum unless we are somehow at lylo and I dont think thats the case
---

Wait so it calls witches monsters and you didn't think anything of FD's claim, mzero?
---

I'd be pissed if FD and Chris are the only two Scum remaining and the game has just pilfered out because it's been solved, and I'm over here overthinking it but... I have a feeling neither of them are.

Maybe one is still likely. If Chris is Scum, he knows he doesn't have to try as hard to prevent his lynch because he saw how quickly everyone was to jump on FD when he said so.

The thing that this Town is lacking is some leadership, and that's obvious enough. Scum Chris could very easily say "people have said FD is suspicious, nobody is really doing much, so I just need to push Town in that direction and they'll plow through on their own" then sit back and watch the fireworks.

As far as FD goes... idk, I haven't reread D1 yet (sorry) but this is starting to feel like one of those "oh, people are saying they're going to lynch FD... whatever, afk until end of day oh woops he's Town" sorts of lynches.

And here comes Scummy Red with the 'wait, my flavor says something bout hunting witches' like hell naw brother you ain't getting shit without giving us more info there.
---

Has no one given a reason by the way why a town FD would make the claims list crap
---

Dude the only people I even see as possible scum now are FD, Chris, and Sbell. Literally everyone else is either in or being put through the process of being in THE OFFICIAL BOOK OF CONFIRMED TOWN
---

ScareChan posted...

What does this do at all? Who or what does this help?

It helps me because I've been unable to keep straight on the nonsense that been involved with chains this game. For example I'm entirely unclear on everything regarding Neablis and his role/action.

.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Fd coming in with clear intent to come after me but then going really soft is a bad look. And unless I missed it I dont know what plum has to do with my alignment really.

Yesterday seemed like it was "plum OR chris", but now it's fairly muddled.

.

ScareChan posted...

I refuse to believe that Town FD who was -1 last night and almost quick killed a handfull of hours into day uses his spare moments before he has to be busy for the day and away from game

....making a claims list

Well I did do that and I'm going to continue to. Maybe your expectations are in need of being altered.

.

benjamin3740 posted...

I found it kind of odd FD acts like this is a breadcrumb or something, when he only started doing it in the fifteen minutes before he claimed.

That was the first time I was being asked about myself. Had I not decided to claim on the next page then there would have been more time between.

.

Y'all are being fairly ridiculous with regard to me this game. I'm not even sure what I can reasonably do about it. I guess we're just fucked this game.
---

ScareChan posted...

red13n posted...

ok I'm dumb. You know how I said I don't pay attention to flavor.

Well, I just went and actually read my flavor.

My flavor specifically mentions hunting witches.

I think FD claimed his real flavor as scum.

yes looking for dracula is mentioned in our flavor

and I think that red doesnt go out of his way to make this up as scum unless we are somehow at lylo and I dont think thats the case

This is a little more specific where I would actually wonder if IGCD actually put the flavor of the Scum members into Town flavors.

If anybody else has a specific 'monster' to point out, by all means.
---

ScareChan posted...

Has no one given a reason by the way why a town FD would make the claims list crap

I just gave one and you are starting to make me upset. Q
---

ScareChan posted...

Has no one given a reason by the way why a town FD would make the claims list crap

because doing frivolous things is what FD does.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Wait so it calls witches monsters and you didn't think anything of FD's claim, mzero?

I forgot about it! I just checked now after red's post and sure enough it's in there
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Dude the only people I even see as possible scum now are FD, Chris, and Sbell. Literally everyone else is either in or being put through the process of being in THE OFFICIAL BOOK OF CONFIRMED TOWN

I'm in the lynch FD, lynch Sbell, auto-win game pile at this point.

Unless something dumb happened like godfather sheep.
---

Forceful_Dragon posted...

ScareChan posted...

Has no one given a reason by the way why a town FD would make the claims list crap

I just gave one and you are starting to make me upset. Q

This is not your walls where you post commentary Your claims list being posted in topic does noting but fake content. It serves no purpose to the game itself the way you made it.
---

The main reason I can think of to not mass claim is to leave Chris alive, hope that he's Town and that Scum confirm him by killing him because they're afraid of the only power claim that's not masons.
---

I have nothing insightful to say about this game. It's been a mess of people saying dumb things that don't have any logical connections or inferences. If I made normal walls it would be me saying how about I am about everyone all the time.
---

Well analyzing the claim game isnt fruitful.

Who do you even think is scum right now and why
---

Forceful_Dragon posted...

I have nothing insightful to say about this game

we noticed this one awhile ago FD.
---

hold off on mass

force scum to shoot me, ben, or chris
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

The main reason I can think of to not mass claim is to leave Chris alive, hope that he's Town and that Scum confirm him by killing him because they're afraid of the only power claim that's not masons.

unless you have a major card to play, I prefer to keep scum in the dark here. Especially with masons on the board still(If masons are scum we were fucked long ago).
---

ScareChan posted...

hold off on mass

force scum to shoot me, ben, or chris

basically, this. we cant lose ben/scare at night.

unless it happened again where scum held an extra kill. I'm not betting on this because they'd likely have wiped masons off the board forever ago in that case.
---

red13n posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

The main reason I can think of to not mass claim is to leave Chris alive, hope that he's Town and that Scum confirm him by killing him because they're afraid of the only power claim that's not masons.

unless you have a major card to play, I prefer to keep scum in the dark here. Especially with masons on the board still(If masons are scum we were fucked long ago).

Every time you say that you make me depressed that I'm not scum
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Every time you say that you make me depressed that I'm not scum

you two claiming masons immediately made me wish we were all 3 just a scumteam again.
---

and not plum
---

red13n posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

The main reason I can think of to not mass claim is to leave Chris alive, hope that he's Town and that Scum confirm him by killing him because they're afraid of the only power claim that's not masons.

unless you have a major card to play, I prefer to keep scum in the dark here. Especially with masons on the board still(If masons are scum we were fucked long ago).

It might be a major card, might be nothing. I guess I can play it, just need to ask SBell and FD a question.

SBell, FD: is your role (the thing listed in parentheses) vanilla?
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

red13n posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

The main reason I can think of to not mass claim is to leave Chris alive, hope that he's Town and that Scum confirm him by killing him because they're afraid of the only power claim that's not masons.

unless you have a major card to play, I prefer to keep scum in the dark here. Especially with masons on the board still(If masons are scum we were fucked long ago).

It might be a major card, might be nothing. I guess I can play it, just need to ask SBell and FD a question.

SBell, FD: is your role (the thing listed in parentheses) vanilla?

OH SNAP

Hey should they same time answer, just in case? I have no insight if this is helpful, but is it?
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

SBell, FD: is your role (the thing listed in parentheses) vanilla?

Yes
---

Forceful_Dragon posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

SBell, FD: is your role (the thing listed in parentheses) vanilla?

Yes

Welp, there goes same time

Also you said you were mint chocolate chip earlier and not vanilla LYNCH ALL LIARS
---

Han if you were trying to go where I think you were going to go with that, those type of things would have been taken care of by host on the scumboard.
---

This was really disappointing.

##vote: FD
---

red13n posted...

Forceful_Dragon posted...

I have nothing insightful to say about this game

we noticed this one awhile ago FD.

God DAMN
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Forceful_Dragon posted...

I spoke about chris
I spoke about the chris/plum situations and how I felt that it was going to resolve itself with plum's lynch

I have believed in miller masons since day 1.
But I don't like it when everyone changes their claims every 30 minutes to suit their particular whim.

I haven't been keeping a master list of all claims like I normally do. In part because of laziness, but in part because it sucks being vanilla when everyone else has crazy shit.

I said that i've felt people have been laying the groundwork for my mislynch, but I already said my feelings on that.

I have not developed any new feelings on those issues since the last time I've said something regarding them.

I do have a new feeling, which is one of being upset that you are making me feel as though I have not been pulling my weight, when I do not think that is the case.

Am I supposed to repeat myself every 6 hours on things where my feelings and opinions have stayed the same?

And it's been a long day so i'm going to sleep now. If you are curious what my thoughts are before I wake up, feel free to read something I've already said. Unless I have some really trippy mafia dreams it will still be an accurate representation of my thoughts.

If this is what you thought, then why when Plum asked us to lynch Chris when he flipped town did you say "No Deal" ???

---

benjamin3740 posted...

Forceful_Dragon posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

When you ask questions, often times you will get an answer.

Yeah I asked questions too and was told that those answers were not relevant to me.

Wait you asked about how Chris' role works? How/why?

---

benjamin3740 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Forceful_Dragon posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

When you ask questions, often times you will get an answer.

Yeah I asked questions too and was told that those answers were not relevant to me.

Wait you asked about how Chris' role works? How/why?

To see if I could verify anything about prosty and it's potential implimentation. Every other site send to use prosty in lieu of RBer and ours usually involves the person knowing they were slept with.

But I was told that information was need to know and did not need to know
---

benjamin3740 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Forceful_Dragon posted...

I spoke about chris
I spoke about the chris/plum situations and how I felt that it was going to resolve itself with plum's lynch

I have believed in miller masons since day 1.
But I don't like it when everyone changes their claims every 30 minutes to suit their particular whim.

I haven't been keeping a master list of all claims like I normally do. In part because of laziness, but in part because it sucks being vanilla when everyone else has crazy shit.

I said that i've felt people have been laying the groundwork for my mislynch, but I already said my feelings on that.

I have not developed any new feelings on those issues since the last time I've said something regarding them.

I do have a new feeling, which is one of being upset that you are making me feel as though I have not been pulling my weight, when I do not think that is the case.

Am I supposed to repeat myself every 6 hours on things where my feelings and opinions have stayed the same?

And it's been a long day so i'm going to sleep now. If you are curious what my thoughts are before I wake up, feel free to read something I've already said. Unless I have some really trippy mafia dreams it will still be an accurate representation of my thoughts.

If this is what you thought, then why when Plum asked us to lynch Chris when he flipped town did you say "No Deal" ???

I was being flippant, but also thought plum was definitely scum at the time.
---