Board 8 > English Literature Mafia Topic 3: Is the prologue over yet?

(+) Yeah! (+)

Oh hey yeah shouldn't Ben be trying to kill Chris or something
---

Obellisk posted...

Hey Corrik, hypothetical.

Hb is town.

Which votes on him are scum.

Who knows. Ask Chris. I don't even know who is on him.
---

Lea
---

Corrik7 posted...

Obellisk posted...

Hey Corrik, hypothetical.

Hb is town.

Which votes on him are scum.

Who knows. Ask Chris. I don't even know who is on him.

You, Chris, Death, Lea, Puns, and Tom.

Which of those six do you find the scummiest.
---

Hbthebattle posted...

It was not an hour iirc, and I didnt see his post when I made mine.

Who cares what you saw then I'm asking what you see now. You have been looking into me and Ben do you have anything?
---

Lopen posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

It was not an hour iirc, and I didnt see his post when I made mine.

Who cares what you saw then I'm asking what you see now. You have been looking into me and Ben do you have anything?

I think youre scum.

Im unsure with Ben, his play hasnt suggested scumminess but the fact people didnt jump on him like they did with me is worrying.
---

You think I'm scum why? I asked you for a reason and you just admitted you were mistaken and didn't see the post from Ulti
---

Lopen posted...

You think I'm scum why? I asked you for a reason and you just admitted you were mistaken and didn't see the post from Ulti

Lopen, would you like to join our merry band of thieves consisting of me and Chris? Let's form a bloc. With our powers combined....
---

When I said it was notable nobody would jump on Mzero Ulti said that was an argument scum made in the last game :(
---

My role's ability lets me change my vote as many times per day as I please Corrik, worry not.
---

Lopen posted...

My role's ability lets me change my vote as many times per day as I please Corrik, worry not.

I believe your claim, but I didn't really ask for it. I asked if you would like to commit your vote to the greater good. Would you care to put the village above your own self? As a true hero would...
---

I think wagons not forming on just anyone is a sign of the effort put forth. The cases on Mzero and Ben were lower effort so they didn't get wagons as easily. Says nothing about alignments

Though I am curious, hb, who on your lynch you suspect if you think it's getting momentum because of scum influence. Neither me nor Ben are even on it!
---

Lopen posted...

I think wagons not forming on just anyone is a sign of the effort put forth. The cases on Mzero and Ben were lower effort so they didn't get wagons as easily. Says nothing about alignments

Though I am curious, hb, who on your lynch you suspect if you think it's getting momentum because of scum influence. Neither me nor Ben are even on it!

Ive talked about Lea and Puns, havent I? And as youve self-admitted, youre on my lynch in spirit.
---

Corrik7 posted...

Would you care to put the village above your own self? As a true hero would...

B... B... But... target bomb...

Wait what I'm voting, sbell? Not sure he's scum yet quite frankly just think he's biased because he knows I don't think highly of him (NO OFFENSE NO MODKILL PLZ)
---

RogueNoble posted...

Oh hey yeah shouldn't Ben be trying to kill Chris or something

my point exactly
---

Basically, Chris is Ridley. I am Snails.

I think you would be a good Elwood, Lopen.
---

And the way youve reacted to me this game reminds me of how I reacted to Ben last game: blowing me off with saying I have no solid argument and then supporting a lynch train that built on me.
---

HB did the 'I can confirm this is false because of my own flavor' thing in Endgame mafia too yeah.
more fuel for the fire.
---

Are you kidding me?

I built your train and you admitted your argument had holes and have made no effort to correct it or revise it despite me giving you opportunities to
---

Howdy!

I'm reading back from previous topic page 4

You say you built my train, but then you disassociate with it here.

Lopen posted...

I think wagons not forming on just anyone is a sign of the effort put forth. The cases on Mzero and Ben were lower effort so they didn't get wagons as easily. Says nothing about alignments

Though I am curious, hb, who on your lynch you suspect if you think it's getting momentum because of scum influence. Neither me nor Ben are even on it!

Which is it, Lopen? Clocks ticking.
---

Just so dudes know where I'm at with reads

Playerlist (21 alive)
1. Pezloco - hes fine, nothing egregious, not even that SK nonsense
2. UltimaterializerX - I liked Ulti calling out Lea3lea on why Lea3Lea assumed Ulti thought Chris was Town, but not much more than that // Uncertain (lean town)
3. Lea3Lea - Not Mafia with MKZero// Feels self-aware // Possibly TMIed Sir Chris being Town // HOWEVER, good activity // Uncertain, requires pressure
4. Red13n - seems to be cross referencing games which is more likely solid scum hunting effort //Town
5. Benjamin - Engaging, looking for answers rather than stirring the port // Town
6. SBell (Obellisk) - haven't read
7. Camarija - Town Opera Singer
8. MZero - Not Mafia with Lea3Lea// accused of post fluff// Lean Town
9. Sir Chris (DoomTheGyarados) - Town
10. 5tarscream - they actually read the first thread lol // Lean Town
11. Hbthebattle - lovely gentleman, but no read yet // Uncertain
12. Death (HtaeD) - haven't read
13. Tom Bombadil - Town, not much more to say
14. TheSultanOfSlam - haven't read
15. Lopen - Dirty read but feels Town due to asking about the voting stuff / Lean Town
16. turbopuns3 - Probably a Town Gambit opener / Lean Town
17. eaedwards - haven't read
18. Corrik - Probably Town if my tinfoil is correct / Tinfoil Town
19. Luis_Sera - haven't read
20. Lolo_Guru - haven't read
21. dowolf - Low Impact, asks questions that dont go anywhere / Lean Mafia

I built your train but, factually, I'm not currently on it, yet it has a lot of votes. So it stands to reason if your claim is you must be town because there are scum on the lynch that you have people on there you think are likely scum
---

Lopen posted...

I built your train but, factually, I'm not currently on it, yet it has a lot of votes. So it stands to reason if your claim is you must be town because there are scum on the lynch that you have people on there you think are likely scum

And Ive said my suspicions on Lea and Puns, havent I?
---

RogueNoble posted...

Oh hey yeah shouldn't Ben be trying to kill Chris or something

Why is that?
---

benjamin3740 posted...

RogueNoble posted...

Oh hey yeah shouldn't Ben be trying to kill Chris or something

Why is that?

(6) Hb: Chris, Lea, puns, Tom, Corrik, Death
(2) Lopen: Ulti, Hb
(1) Sir Chris: (Tom), Ben, (puns)
(1) No Lynch: pezloco, (Tom), (Lopen)
(1) Cam: Lopen
(1) Dowolf: Cam
(1) Corrik: Sultan
(0) Ben: (Chris), (Corrik), (Lea)
(0) Luis: (Lea)
(0) Lea: (Cam)
(0) MZero: (Lea)
(0) Ulti: (Lopen), (Hb)
(0) Puns: (Lea), (Corrik), (Ulti)
---

Lopen posted...

think he's biased because he knows I don't think highly of him (NO OFFENSE NO MODKILL PLZ)

It is you who thinks poorly of me, I've only ever taken it from you. However I do not let any outside game relations interfere with game play.

I actually think your jokes, while humorous, point to scum.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

RogueNoble posted...

Oh hey yeah shouldn't Ben be trying to kill Chris or something

Why is that?

You did vote him, you know.
---

Corrik7 posted...

Speaking of, Cam has been a ghost. That is not his normal town playstyle.

what is cam here, 1 scum game 1 town game?

i dont think inactivity has been a part of either.
---

Obellisk posted...

However I do not let any outside game relations interfere with game play.

Example. I play Mafia with Ulti.
---

red13n posted...

Corrik7 posted...

Speaking of, Cam has been a ghost. That is not his normal town playstyle.

what is cam here, 1 scum game 1 town game?

i dont think inactivity has been a part of either.

Idk I played one game with him. He was town. He tried to be overly clever to try and find scum. And used graphs to show scum is usually less active. Less active means scum to him where he comes from.
---

@Lea3Lea

The conclusion of this logic should be why you assumed Ulti views Chris as Town

Ok, I can more or less wrap my head around your transitive logic haha but that was a trip

I get that a lot
---

Hello @red13n @Corrik7

I play most games with entirely different styles and personalities!

This game is no exception :D

Thanks for the speculation, but seeing as I'm clearly present, you could always just talk to me now :)

Camarija posted...

Hello @red13n @Corrik7

I play most games with entirely different styles and personalities!

This game is no exception :D

Thanks for the speculation, but seeing as I'm clearly present, you could always just talk to me now :)

Ok
---

Cam, why do you say I'm gambiting

Hrm, currentHB hasnt done a lot of what past scumHB did... and thats building up networks of scum/town based off of yet to be established facts.
If anything he sounded slightly more insightful in endgame mafia!
Thats not really convincing me of him currently tho.
---

did ben really pop in here, wonder why we expect him to go aftrer someone, and immediately leave?
---

Hbthebattle posted...

And Ive said my suspicions on Lea and Puns, havent I?

Not with enough depth or conviction to my liking but it's possible I didn't read it well enough as I'm on mobile and as such have been somewhat speeding over stuff not directly aimed at me for now

I'll look at your cases on them later today but for now my phone is dying so see ya in a few hours.
---

dowolf posted...

did ben really pop in here, wonder why we expect him to go aftrer someone, and immediately leave?

i believe he was spouting an obvious flawed defense for hb at some point recently.
---

dowolf posted...

RogueNoble posted...

Oh hey yeah shouldn't Ben be trying to kill Chris or something

my point exactly

What have I said to show I think Chris is scum outside of voting him before he even made his first post?
---

dowolf posted...

did ben really pop in here, wonder why we expect him to go aftrer someone, and immediately leave?

I shouldn't be posting at all. Im at work. And it was less of a "wondering" question and more of a setup for the next question
---

Oh, ok, you don't think Chris is scum, you're just not actually scum hunting

Much better!
---

turbopuns3 posted...

Cam, why do you say I'm gambiting

Because I see far more scenarios where you aren't being honest than where you are, regarding your miller claim

Camarija posted...

turbopuns3 posted...

Cam, why do you say I'm gambiting

Because I see far more scenarios where you aren't being honest than where you are, regarding your miller claim

Well obviously. There is only one scenario where I'm being honest. Lol

Gtg to work soon i would have liked to be more active today but unfortunately i wasnt

Still really dislike corriks play thus far so my vote will stay for now ill come back on my break while I'm here for a few mins ask me stuff
---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Gtg to work soon i would have liked to be more active today but unfortunately i wasnt

Still really dislike corriks play thus far so my vote will stay for now ill come back on my break while I'm here for a few mins ask me stuff

Disliking someone's play and thinking someone is scum are very different
---

Obellisk posted...

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Gtg to work soon i would have liked to be more active today but unfortunately i wasnt

Still really dislike corriks play thus far so my vote will stay for now ill come back on my break while I'm here for a few mins ask me stuff

Disliking someone's play and thinking someone is scum are very different

Well in this case its both or at the least anti town one tracked mind a being a lap dog isnt good for a good player like corrik to do i feel like its more or less let me latch on to chris but chris hasnt done any truly town defining play so its just odd and corrik i think would try harder as town
---

RogueNoble posted...

Oh, ok, you don't think Chris is scum, you're just not actually scum hunting

Much better!

I town hunt first and foremost. My most accurate scum reads are usually "I have no town reads on this person"
---

theaD aka Death is on my scum radar now

Checking them out in further detail