Board 8 > Baseball Musical Mafia Topic 1 - Of Singing and Slugging - 7PM Start Time!

(+) Yeah! (+)

Out of all the votes on BCT Lopens does look the worst

BUT his immediate unvote realizing the vote is high give him slight town points here.

Ulti usually for me if scum makes it a little obvious at some point. I have not seen that defining post yet. So though he has been a bit wild dont have the scum tell on him.

All the votes that were on me Hans was the worst

But after his unvote he says he is ok ending the day early

how does that make sense

Why

Han not giving explanation doesnt concern me. He is the best pure gut player in the game.

Strongly suggest we end day in a tie because random draw will do better than usual day 1s.

I didn't like ctes's posts on page 1 or Hb's check-in post.

And Ulti, I don't think you came to the correct conclusion on Lopen.

BCT I'm holding judgment on since his post said nothing (it's not hard to post differently from last game when his posts were "what happens on D1?" He just has to pretend to have at least 1 game experience to post differently I mean come on).

Also, I can get behind Lea.

##Vote: Sultan

I don't anticipate being around as much today so I'll send you my bow Lea. I'm not sure how I feel about the way SBell hopped on though. Would someone typing up a post throw it away because you said a similar thing? Did SBell really think the same things, or is he just pretending to? I will keep these thoughts in mind.

Ulti just goes balls out. That's not necessarily alignment indicating. He is more likely to be a bit more on the withheld side as Scum, tho

Sultan I'm just unsure on, that's all. I don't know why he has 5 votes so quickly and that makes me think something is off. No idea what to make of it all.

Good:
Han because Hangut is strong here, and he seems like he's analyzing like town Gan did last game.

He is the best pure gut player in the game.

Obelisk - I want him to live just to spite Ulti for giggles, even if both are town.

Can you clarify what you mean here?

Grannet I hope a scum just shoots themself in the foot and we kill scum

but I dont hate this idea.

Just getting back to Isquen's post... dafuq does this even mean?

Isquen are you saying that Plum/BCT player slot is town?

Question isquen if you had a vig shot who would it be and why?

Hell no, not at this juncture.

I am not a day one shooter, and my vote is where it is for a reason.

Why couldn't you just say a name?

Because using day 1 vigilante is stupid and does not spark town joy.

Because using day 1 vigilante is stupid and does not spark town joy.

Also makes little sense why Sultan was so accepting of your response.

Referring mostly to Ulti in two games now I've noticed doing nothing in postgame but saying "you suck" specifically to you. Or maybe Kirby, I dunno.

Then why did you unvote him?

I actually do find Sultan's day 1 somewhat similar to this game. He makes some accusations that seem to be accusations made just to make something. He vote on Ben feels pretty similar. This time the heat got off of him partly because BCT stole the spotlight, but I think it's very similar.

In general, I don't think Lopen's thought process has been consistent

I would like him to explain what he was thinking and why his thoughts led to the posts he made

1. Before BCT claimed
2. When he didn't like the lynch train
3. After BCT claimed
4. When I replaced BCT / said that BCT was lying about his claim

Plum could you answer my earlier question.
Did you think people seriously wanted to lynch Corrik?

When it looked like IGCD was a funny day vig? Yes.

Day vig through infinite votes sounds like a pretty wacky role that would fit here

When it looked like IGCD was a funny day vig? Yes.

Day vig through infinite votes sounds like a pretty wacky role that would fit here

I thought it was a little outta character but the rest of his play has been fine

Can I ask why we're putting plum out of contention? That slot looked awful when BCT had it, and plum trying to walk it back hasn't really erased that.

Now with 10% more braincells, I commit my empty thoughts to paper.

Plum - Looks awful because of BCT's digestion of their own foot. I like to vote against someone on a day 1 train, but I could be convinced.
Ben - About the only thing I like so far is the Corrik vote. Everything else is very similar to scum play I've seen in the past few times he's been scum.
changmas - Good vibes from 'em, even suspecting me. I can dig it.
Corrik - The whole "random it out teehee :)" thing won't ever work (Christ, I have a harder time wrangling five people to do D&D in the same time zones, sixteen won't work especially if there's a hammerer or something like it.) Corrik usually is a wild card, but I smell a rat.
ctes - I only have my initial bad vibe to go off of, which isn't much. Still.
Death - Alive past Day 0 obvscum. But really, gotta reread their things.
IGCD - Kudos.
Isquen - Handsome.
Han - Hansome
HB - Sweet boy points expired, please try again.
Lea - Good vibes halted because of agreeing to Corrik's random plan, and further thrown into disarray by questioning people and providing nothing in return.
Lopen - Red flag on the horizon that I must be vague about. I'm voting them for my own reasons.
Obelisk - I want him to live just to spite Ulti for giggles, even if both are town.
red13n - Hides and pokes bears for a living, but does this both as town and scum, so I dunno.
Sultan - The aforementioned sense of being here before, during Souls Mafia. Also the immediate piggyback on a vote.
Ulti - Good vibes, again, but also a similar chaos elemental as Corrik day 1. None or little of the usual self-importance bravado I'm accustomed to, I'll note.

I sally onwards to my eight hours of indentured servitude to the Man with an update to the vibe check.

Groovy:
Changmas
Lea

Grody:
Ben
Sultan

1. Before BCT claimed
2. When he didn't like the lynch train
3. After BCT claimed
4. When I replaced BCT / said that BCT was lying about his claim

1. I feel like there is a case with meat building on this person unlike Sultan/Ben where I saw votes but not people adding to the case. I'll put a vote because we need pressure on someone to get some good content and haven't really had any yet.
2. Already stated in my previous post. I will note that I also removed the vote because I wanted BCT some chance to react before we hit a critical mass because I actually know BCT's personality to some level (he had me blocked for years for the most mundane comment-- so him having a Crescent like meltdown is something I was being a bit cautious of) and I wouldn't have made it at all if I saw Lea's vote sandwiched in there. I think Red probably knows BCT's personality too as a long time B8 user and that's why I saw his vote as predatory after saying BCT was likely town.
3. This is clearly a fake claim because BCT claimed this role was super important to town and would lose town the game, and a town RB simply isn't very important. BCT's obsession with the anti-claim mechanic makes it plausible it was town fakeclaiming though. BCT's lack of attempt to actually get votes off of him makes it less plausible he was town though because the strategy isn't there-- why fakeclaim and then just let yourself die.
4. Replacement makes it likely BCT tilted massively and didn't defend himself due to that, thus more plausible he was town despite his play not making sense with a fakeclaim.

Now with 10% more braincells, I commit my empty thoughts to paper.

Plum - Looks awful because of BCT's digestion of their own foot. I like to vote against someone on a day 1 train, but I could be convinced.
Ben - About the only thing I like so far is the Corrik vote. Everything else is very similar to scum play I've seen in the past few times he's been scum.
changmas - Good vibes from 'em, even suspecting me. I can dig it.
Corrik - The whole "random it out teehee :)" thing won't ever work (Christ, I have a harder time wrangling five people to do D&D in the same time zones, sixteen won't work especially if there's a hammerer or something like it.) Corrik usually is a wild card, but I smell a rat.
ctes - I only have my initial bad vibe to go off of, which isn't much. Still.
Death - Alive past Day 0 obvscum. But really, gotta reread their things.
IGCD - Kudos.
Isquen - Handsome.
Han - Hansome
HB - Sweet boy points expired, please try again.
Lea - Good vibes halted because of agreeing to Corrik's random plan, and further thrown into disarray by questioning people and providing nothing in return.
Lopen - Red flag on the horizon that I must be vague about. I'm voting them for my own reasons.
Obelisk - I want him to live just to spite Ulti for giggles, even if both are town.
red13n - Hides and pokes bears for a living, but does this both as town and scum, so I dunno.
Sultan - The aforementioned sense of being here before, during Souls Mafia. Also the immediate piggyback on a vote.
Ulti - Good vibes, again, but also a similar chaos elemental as Corrik day 1. None or little of the usual self-importance bravado I'm accustomed to, I'll note.

thats 1 person though.

I read half of topic 1 there, so if it starts being less similar for there then that's great, but I said I hadn't read further. I also noted that Star Wars and Pokmon mafia weren't that different, noting there wasn't that strong a case.