Board 8 > Baseball Musical Mafia Topic 8 - RIP Vin Scully

(+) Yeah! (+)

THE LIVING

1. Ben
2. Corrik
3. ctes
4. Death
5. IGCD
6. Han
7. HB
8. Obelisk
9. red13n
10. Sultan
11. Ulti

THE DEAD
MasterPlum - Town Jailkeeper [LD1]
Changmas - Town Taunter [KN1]
Lopen - Mafia Godfather [KD2]
Isquen - Town Doctor [LD2]
Lea - Town Miller Backup [KN2]

Oh, and Han has been Poisoned and WILL, 100%, die at End of Day.

With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Day ends in about 55 or so minutes, at 7pm EST.

Also an advance warning that my darling players will not be getting any cool flavor this evening, as I have to wrap things up quick and any flavor will be posted at some point over night.

Like, Red, the reason I'm so down with this plan is that, if Corrik is Town, it clears a wide swath of people. It ensures two people are Scum with Corrik's flip - probably 3 after he gets a scan in tomorrow.

If Corrik wasn't actually Day Cop, then I pretty easily just lynch SBell here. But I believe he might be which makes the plan more important, because it accounts for a possible Scum Corrik.

Sbell, I'm just going to verify, you think your buoletproof thing can be beat by scum "out of nowhere "?

This isn't that tough a question

Leafeon13N posted...

Sbell, I'm just going to verify, you think your buoletproof thing can be beat by scum "out of nowhere "?

I think that it would be foolish to think that the anticlaim mechanic can't be used to subvert town power. That is my entire line of thinking.

Leafeon13N posted...

This isn't that tough a question

mobile, been ignoring my kids all day working, please have patience.

Okay well in this case I'm going to have to counterclaim and specifically mention that i am informed that scum has ways to murder mem

Man gamefaqs was not letting me post the votals for some reason.

Cmon

[4] No Lynch - Han, Ben, IGCD, SBell
[3] SBell - (Ulti), (Ben), Ulti, Sultan, Corrik
[1] HB - (Han), (Sultan), (Ulti), ctes
[1] IGCD - HB, (Ulti)
[1] Corrik - (Han), (Ben), (Han), (Corrik), (Ben), Death
[0] Ben - (Sultan), (Han), (Ulti)
[0] ctes - (Ulti)
[0] Death - (Han), (Ben)
[0] Red - (Ulti)
[0] Ulti - (Han)

I thought maybe there were two of us and sbell sounded like a clone now it sounds like my initial take may have been mistaken.

Also wait what?
Mem who?

The last m was a period

Oh
OH

...
##Unvote
##Vote: Sbell

No wait...what Ulti said.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Red, a couple of the same points apply. Specifically, Ben. Have you suspected him at all this game?

Yes.

But also role madness.

##Unvote: No Lynch

I'll take it.

##vote: sbell

I'm not confident confident. But he doesn't add up with my description of bulletproof, which heavily implies it not being as useful as it seems.

Sbell didnt answer me what he thought about Corrik either, did he?

Because if he thought Corrik was lying, I dont know why he would go with plan NL unless it was for wholly selfish reasons.

Though the idea of two bulletproofs in a game with a gambit gun isn't too far-fetched.

I just wish Ctes had been around to get a full image of where his mind was at.

Also please please please nobody hammer.

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Though the idea of two bulletproofs in a game with a gambit gun isn't too far-fetched.

I just wish Ctes had been around to get a full image of where his mind was at.

It didn't seem farfetched to me either. This is why i was prodding him hard to say if he had some reasoning to think his bulletproof was fallible. I gave him multiple outs to walk it back or expand on it a little and he didn't.

Oh right 6 to lynch

##Unvote

Hell he didn't even need to be exact, just a "yes i have reasons" would have given me pause.

Jumped the a gun a bit there maybe, but that vote is going right back in the final few minutes

UltimaterializerX posted...

Three. Ben, for all intensive purposes, is basically a bulletproof.

that's not fuxking true at all. you shoot him he fuxking dies.

I will go ahead and say that the simplest answer for this game is that SBell, Death, and one of IGCD/Hb are Scum (Hb makes 10x more sense as Scum based on lack of interactions with Lopen and basically posting nothing except for D1 when I was hounding him, and IGCD countering Isquen when that play is directly suicidal if ICGD is Scum. That play only really makes sense if Scum knew Isquen's role).

UltimaterializerX posted...

Three. Ben, for all intensive purposes, is basically a bulletproof.

I would implore you to read Ben's claims and the posts around it before chiming in with something unrelated like this.

Obellisk posted...

that's not fuxking true at all. you shoot him he fuxking dies.

This is what you respond to?

Leafeon13N posted...

Hell he didn't even need to be exact, just a "yes i have reasons" would have given me pause.

we all know the anticlaim mechanic affects town members in a negative way.

you asked if I had reason to believe it would directly kill me. and my reasons are from my head. host did not give me specific knowledge I'd get dead if they knew I was BP at time of shooting me.

He said he is not nightkill proof tho.
Though now I am curious if Ben got similar warnings in his description.

Leafeon13N posted...

This is what you respond to?

SASS

Okay if nothing else Sbell is making me laugh.

Obellisk posted...

you asked if I had reason to believe it would directly kill me. and my reasons are from my head. host did not give me specific knowledge I'd get dead if they knew I was BP at time of shooting me.

I asked very specifically for specific reasons.

To thread the needle a bit, i obviously know what information is in my role pm and logic that could follow or be learned from that.

I'd expect you to have something along similar lines than just "I'm bulletproof".

You claimed to have nothing and thus i am left to think you are missing some information you should habe with that role.

Anyway, there is "room for error" in that group of Scum (SBell, Death, Hb/IGCD), but things are pretty good there if this pans out.

Here's a quick knock of the "Scummiest" actions that players have taken, aside from that:

Ctes - Hangut

Red - Was buying Lopen's claim on D2

Ben - Hey remember when he PURPOSEFULLY KILLED THE DOCTOR INSTEAD OF GIVING HIM A 50% CHANCE TO LIVE? Ben not thinking the mechanic worked that way is forgivable, but this isn't the first "oops I didn't read lol" thing of the game from Ben.

Ulti - I didn't get into this, but Ulti soft-defended Lopen in topic 1 some. 1.304, said to lynch Plum anyway, even though he had been harping on Lopen for red flags. Ulti claimed the exact same thing that Lopen suggested might be possible (a role that gets stronger surviving two days). Also, Ulti soft-defended Lopen using me in post 1.321. Anyway, those are some of the Scummier things, but Ulti's innocence really belongs to Corrik.

Corrik - Tried to direct Sultan to insta-shot Ulti at the beginning of day 2. This is forgivable if SBell flips Scum here. Honest, Corrik hasn't really been too Scummy aside from that this game.

Wow people bounced fast huh

Sbell hasn't had much of a response.

Indeed.
I guess I didn't need to unvote.

Leafeon13N posted...

Sbell hasn't had much of a response.

I'm town. I could vote you and say you lie. but who is here to listen

I shrug. we move on.

Good luck guys.

htaeD posted...

Indeed.
I guess I didn't need to unvote.

I'm dying, Squirtle

I will miss you Bidoof

Actually, I can't wait to join Dead Town Chat. Lea and I can commiserate about how we didn't do too well. We can laugh about the Scumteam actually being Corrik/Ulti/Ben, who have skirted by because everyone assumes they're just lying so they're never challenged. I can apologize to Isquen and Plum. Chang will be there.

Obellisk posted...

I'm town. I could vote you and say you lie. but who is here to listen

I shrug. we move on.

Good luck guys.

There is literally a whole group of people here to listen you better not be town.

Okay?
Whats the reason this time?