Board 8 > Xenoblade Chronicles 3 Mafia: 1-1 Welcome to the World of Aionios

(+) Yeah! (+)

htaeD posted...

Also IGCD, Bens OP is not bad at all.

Basically the whole world in XB3 is against Moebius. Not just the two factions.

That literally has nothing to do with what I said.

masterplum posted...

I was in a terrible spot because I knew nobody would ever believe I was telling the truth so I was left with claiming post 1 or refusing to claim anything the entire game and hoping nobody ever flavor scanned me.

This is the first thing you've said so far that really feels fake

Yes it does.

Your flavor not being part of the two factions is not an issue in my eyes since I know the lore of the game.
In the end all (well most) characters join forces anyway.

Plum is just an outlyer (Ben is so funny haha) as far as I can see.

Peace___Frog posted...

You've gone back and forth on death more times in the past few hours than a swinging pirate ship at an amusement park. You shot with that little confidence?

This post doesn't make any sense.

Another factor that makes me feel so certain is that Plums claimed flavor doesnt even make sense as a flavor miller if Cobra Kai is the scumteam
IMO

IfGodCouldDie posted...

This post doesn't make any sense.

You shot death because you thought he was scum.
You voted for me because you think i know that you and death are town.
Now you're arguing that me and death are scum.

That's a lot of drastic changes on how you feel about death!

htaeD posted...

Yes it does.

Your flavor not being part of the two factions is not an issue in my eyes since I know the lore of the game.
In the end all (well most) characters join forces anyway.

Plum is just an outlyer (Ben is so funny haha) as far as I can see.

I've already specified that I am not a character in the game either, so the OP is literally lying to the game.

Ah yes. The shot. The shot from IGCD. The shot IGCD specifically made. IGCD's shot.

Okay thats significantly more out there than what I was thinking.
But you didnt specify that technically
You said you werent part of the two factions or a character.
I just assumed you were a location or a weapon.

Well hello new inner voice for Han.

##Vote: Sultan

That was easy.

Also, anyone that voted for Plum is scum or a moron. That guy is unbelievably easy to read, especially when he gets handed goofy town roles. Where is the scum equity in any of his actions so far? You know, outside of doesnt exist.

Deaths reaction to the obviously fake shot was town. Thats two down.

Ulti, don't call people morons.

Unintelligent in the mafia sense of not reading easy people even though theyre totally a perfect soul in real life with no faults ever then.

Just because you lack creativity doesn't mean that others are unintelligent in the Mafia sense

PunishedBen posted...

The Weight of Votals

[2]Plum - Peaf, Lopen, (IGCD), (Corrik)
[1]Chaeix - Edumey
[1]Death - Corrik
[1]Sultan - Han
[1]IGCD - Plum
[1]Peaf - IGCD

Peaf showing up to defend his honor as a scum player!

How many of those four players are town? 2? Maybe 3 on a good day?

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Ulti, don't call people morons.

I dont think he was calling me a moron?
I think he was saying that I haven't shown that I am town beacuse of poorly wording shit like I always do as town?

Nvm you're talking about plum

Feel free to join the flip flopper on me if you are so certain about it being me and not him!

Wasnt talking about you at all, brother. No worries.

Flavor discussion is weird. I don't want to believe IGCD and Plum have Kobra Kai flavors, but I don't really see a reason for IGCD to stick his neck out for Plum unless he IS worried about his flavor being weird. I feel like anyone with that flavor could have kept quiet, and if there was a flavor cop or something that came out with info, could have backed them up then.

I wouldn't be in favor of a full mass claim, but I guess I would be potentially interested in a count of how many people have Xenoblade versus Other flavor. Could give interesting info if those two are the only ones claiming non-Xenoblade, or if more show up.
Whether we decide to or not, I'll just throw my hat out and say I have a Xenoblade flavor.

Peace___Frog posted...

Can we please stop it with the early confident announcements of town alignments? You are allowed to keep notes to yourself on a little note pad app on your phone or pc.

Also this is dumb. Especially early on in the game when we have so little to go off of, starting to mold out town/scum alignments is very helpful to look back at and see who confirmed scum were trying to buddy up with, as well as just general town info.

Ultimaterializer posted...

Wasnt talking about you at all, brother. No worries.

Yeah I realize that.. I apparently cannot read right now. This coffee better kick in soon...

Ulti, my brain may be slow because the morning juices aren't working yet. What prompted the Sultan vote?

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Asked Ben in Discord if it was legit idk

Peaf, you and IGCD are bad lynches today.

Sultan is either scum, a mason, or he needs to be replaced for going outside the game on B8 discord like Isquen did a few games ago, and I dont see a buddy of his standing up to confirm him so that leaves two options. He either screwed up and admitted to asking about this game in the B8 discord (modkill), or he screwed up and let it slip that he was on the scum discord chat.

Its dirty meta but Sultan is the only lynch until he gets confirmed one way or another. Thankfully, I dont think we need meta analysis when hes probably just scum and screwed up his perspective. This is what, the 5th time now someones been caught like this if Sultan actually is scum?

EDumey posted...

I feel like anyone with that flavor could have kept quiet, and if there was a flavor cop or something that came out with info, could have backed them up then.

But wouldn't that lead to like the insta murder of Plum..

Like wtf didn't you claim that! That is such a flavor Miller. I think either way plum is a little fucked either way. But I also don't see scum claiming that

Ultimaterializer posted...

Peaf, you and IGCD are bad lynches today.

Sultan is either scum, a mason, or he needs to be replaced for going outside the game on B8 discord like Isquen did a few games ago, and I dont see a buddy of his standing up to confirm him so that leaves two options. He either screwed up and admitted to asking about this game in the B8 discord (modkill), or he screwed up and let it slip that he was on the scum discord chat.

Its dirty meta but Sultan is the only lynch until he gets confirmed one way or another. Thankfully, I dont think we need meta analysis when hes probably just scum and screwed up his perspective. This is what, the 5th time now someones been caught like this if Sultan actually is scum?

I dont like that argument.

Discord has been used every game since I've started playing mafia on B8.

this is going to look like a counter vote but I dont really like Ulti here

##Vote:Ulti

So have perspective slips, and more often than not the people who mess it up that blatantly are scum.

Sorry man. I came into this game ready to defend your honor after the BS that was just thrown at you (Im genuinely upset about that still but if I say what I actually think about it then I genuinely will never be welcomed to play here again), but I lynch the scums when I think I see the scums.

lol

I respect it.

Ultimaterializer posted...

So have perspective slips, and more often than not the people who mess it up that blatantly are scum.

Sorry man. I came into this game ready to defend your honor after the BS that was just thrown at you (Im genuinely upset about that still but if I say what I actually think about it then I genuinely will never be welcomed to play here again), but I lynch the scums when I think I see the scums.

No worries about the other stuff. The game is the game. If you truly think im scummy so be it.

Can you guys finish the mass claim please

Ultimaterializer posted...

He either screwed up and admitted to asking about this game in the B8 discord (modkill), or he screwed up and let it slip that he was on the scum discord chat.

I could definitely see the slip-up about asking on discord because they were already on a scum chat, so I'm okay with your vote on that account. But isn't it okay to talk ask questions of the Host privately via DM? Unless we found a public post, shouldn't be a modkill for that.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

But wouldn't that lead to like the insta murder of Plum..

Why would you be so invested in someone else getting themselves killed? There's just no reason to stick your neck out for someone intentionally putting themselves in the spotlight claiming they scan scum. (That's also independent of the player meta that Plum always claims Miller IIRC. It's been a few years, so I don't know if that's still a thing.)

I did claim boobs already, didnt I?

That claim was legitimately 100% serious.

EDumey posted...

Why would you be so invested in someone else getting themselves killed? There's just no reason to stick your neck out for someone intentionally putting themselves in the spotlight claiming they scan scum. (That's also independent of the player meta that Plum always claims Miller IIRC. It's been a few years, so I don't know if that's still a thing.)

Not what I am saying.

Say I am the flavor cop and I out Plum as Johnny Lawrence wouldn't that look worse for Plum than Plum just being like hey I got flavor miller, this person isn't even in the game. And I do care if said person is town with me. Can't afford to many mislynches that is how town loses games.

Not sticking my neck out more just saying I think plum is telling the truth. It be wild for scum to make this kind of claim. But maybe I am to trusting of certain people

EDumey posted...

I could definitely see the slip-up about asking on discord because they were already on a scum chat, so I'm okay with your vote on that account. But isn't it okay to talk ask questions of the Host privately via DM? Unless we found a public post, shouldn't be a modkill for that.

Why would you be so invested in someone else getting themselves killed? There's just no reason to stick your neck out for someone intentionally putting themselves in the spotlight claiming they scan scum. (That's also independent of the player meta that Plum always claims Miller IIRC. It's been a few years, so I don't know if that's still a thing.)

Lets pretend the B8 discord doesnt exist and/or all of us are smart enough to keep mafia chatter where it belongs. Town has no reason to ask the host anything in Discord. We dont get access to Discord until after we die.

What reason does Town Sultan have to chat up the host in Discord when a PM (or an in topic @) is our only method of communicating with him?

There isnt one. Occulams Razor says he was chatting up the host on the mafia Discord and got caught.

Also I'm realizing that responding to Sultan saying "you" makes it look like I'm accusing Sultan of sticking their neck out for Plum, but we're talking about IDCD.

current theory is that a la Bens opening post (the flavor part) where he has been isekaid into the game, a number of other random things/characters have been isekaid into the XB3 universe, for starters Johnny Lawrence and thats just Ben doing Ben things

##Unvote:


##Vote: Ulti






Sultans logic on Death was sound and I was getting the same vibes reading his posts.

Ultimaterializer posted...

Lets pretend the B8 discord doesnt exist and/or all of us are smart enough to keep mafia chatter where it belongs. Town has no reason to ask the host anything in Discord. We dont get access to Discord until after we die.

What reason does Town Sultan have to chat up the host in Discord when a PM (or an in topic @) is our only method of communicating with him?

There isnt one. Occulams Razor says he was chatting up the host on the mafia Discord and got caught.

sultan wasnt claiming to chat anyone up on discord though, he was suggesting that Death was doing it

Yeah, I guess I don't see a reason why Town Sultan would feel compelled to DM the host to confirm info currently being discussed in the game. That is the part that makes me believe it could be a tell.

Ultimaterializer posted...

Lets pretend the B8 discord doesnt exist and/or all of us are smart enough to keep mafia chatter where it belongs.

Ignoring the fact that you're not there, there are other discords that i pop into all the time just to chit chat. I don't follow your reasoning at all.

IGCD also said it was a delayed shot and I missed that so if that helps you at all Ulti.

But it still did look almost like Death knows its not a true shot

Peace___Frog posted...

Ignoring the fact that you're not there

Which is still bs

Lopen posted...

##Unvote:


##Vote: Ulti






Sultans logic on Death was sound and I was getting the same vibes reading his posts.

But he admitted it wasnt sound tho.

Also Changmas is paying attention. I like that.

htaeD posted...

But he admitted it wasnt sound tho

Only the part where town could also DM Ben. But again I also missed the part where IGCD said it was delayed.

The look of that it seemed liked you knew it wasn't real stays the same however.

changmas posted...

sultan wasnt claiming to chat anyone up on discord though, he was suggesting that Death was doing it

This was how I read it too. I think Sultan was saying heath could have messaged Ben for confirmation not that he did it himself. However, why didnt Sultan say that himself when Ulti posted that as his evidence? I think Sultan might be scum and thought hed been caught.

masterplum posted...

So IGCD is voting me but says his flavor isnt xenoblade?

Nah

##Vote:IGCd

If one of these two ever flip scum, I want the other lynched as well.

Crudely barging in and calling people morons doesn't help!
But that's separate.

Anyway, sultan, i don't understand how you determine that scum is more likely to know that it's fake than town. Wouldn't scum generally be more likely to believe the claim than not? Since they don't come into games needing to be suspicious of everything.

EDumey posted...

If one of these two ever flip scum, I want the other lynched as well.

Fine by me.

Which one do you want to start with?

Peace___Frog posted...

Fine by me.

Which one do you want to start with?

I don't think that's how it works, bud.