Board 8 > Xenoblade Chronicles 3 Mafia: 1-3 The Topic With The Gall

(+) Yeah! (+)

IGCD whats the music you're playing for my demise?

Plum as town doesn't just give up here

My catch is simple and concise. If it's not an actual catch he could probably walk us through the thought process easily

htaeD posted...

IGCD whats the music you're playing for my demise?

Maxwell's Silver Hammer

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Anything interesting happen? I have skimmed a bit and it seems like Plum has decided to actually be anti-town in his tantrum to my shot.

It's seeming like Scum cfwr and trying to toss out that there is a Cult, which iirc he did hint at earlier in the day, though the way he did it was in a "oh, what if there is a Cult" manner.

Lopen posted...

Plum as town doesn't just give up here

My catch is simple and concise. If it's not an actual catch he could probably walk us through the thought process easily

My problem with it is that i have never caught scum before so odds are he is just tantrumming town and now I'm second guessing myself, but even if he is town at this point there should be enough information for the better players to analyze day one and we move forward tomorrow.

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Maxwell's Silver Hammer

Even when I dont expect it, I get a Beatles reference.

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Maxwell's Silver Hammer

so if you're actually telling the truth, death should die at eod and not overnight?

Damn my work picked up real hard at the end of the day, but I'm here now.

I think with Plum sticking to his guns about his flavor, it is likely that he is a third party rather than normal town. What he said about this game being mostly town and focused around cults though could be true. The only confusion I have is why NO ONE else with a Cobra Kai flavor spoke up to corroborate that idea, unless they think they'd get lynched for it.
Also Plum is playing with such bad etiquette, which is of course funny because he originally got mad about someone not playing the game right. I agree with you Plum that IGCD's action was bad. But zero reason for you to blow up your own game for that and ruin OUR experiences.

If it makes you feel better I'm going to try my best to take 83% credit and make you lost to history

HanOfTheNekos posted...

It's seeming like Scum cfwr and trying to toss out that there is a Cult, which iirc he did hint at earlier in the day, though the way he did it was in a "oh, what if there is a Cult" manner.

And thats the thing, if he is town and there is a cult him actually providing us with whatever information he has regarding his role would only serve to help us, him not doing that is really sus. We don't know what an actual player flip is going to look like.

Lopen posted...

Plum as town doesn't just give up here

My catch is simple and concise. If it's not an actual catch he could probably walk us through the thought process easily

I did

Maybe Plum is the Cult Recruiter. Would explain why his role mentions the Cult Recruiter

Do it again or quote it

masterplum posted...

My role directly refers to a cult recruiter

Does your actual role power refer to a cult recruiter, or just flavor?

Lopen posted...

Do it again or quote it

JCs role makes sense as a cult target

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Maybe Plum is the Cult Recruiter. Would explain why his role mentions the Cult Recruiter

Its almost like there was a reason I didnt want to claim to begin with!

EDumey posted...

Does your actual role power refer to a cult recruiter, or just flavor?

A tubal power

masterplum posted...

Its almost like there was a reason I didnt want to claim to begin with!

It seems like the reason is, in fact, because you're anti-town
##Vote: Plum
Adios!

Hbthebattle posted...

It seems like the reason is, in fact, because you're anti-town
##Vote: Plum
Adios!

See ya

What in the hell is a Tubal power?

We are not lynching death.. corrik

htaeD posted...

What in the hell is a Tubal power?

i googled it myself and got "relating to or occurring in a tube, especially the fallopian tubes". interesting

Hbthebattle posted...

It seems like the reason is, in fact, because you're anti-town
##Vote: Plum
Adios!

I dont like the vote from HB.

masterplum posted...

A tubal power

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/user_image/7/6/6/AAWOdXAAEH2-.png
:thinking:

Yeah, I can't imagine a plum who wants to champion proper play doesn't do so.

Will have to evaluate Death based on this flip. Fellow Scum/Cult member Death, and Plum was mad he got "shot"?

i think it's autocorrected from 'actual' now that i think about it

##unvote
##Vote:Hb

Kill him

Anyways, Im out. Im pretty annoyed which is why I left the first time. Probably would have been better for mental health if I had just never come back but that probably wouldnt have been fair to not give you a punchers chance. Maybe I should have not claimed at all and risked getting insta killed and revealing a flavor scanner. Hard to say.

Well you know its a cult game now, Han isnt acting like town. You should probably kill him.

That's it? That's pitiful. The plum I respect as a strong mafia player (as town) wouldn't abort his suspicion of JC on just that.

EDumey posted...

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/user_image/7/6/6/AAWOdXAAEH2-.png
:thinking:

Yeah that was a typo. It was actual

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

I dont like the vote from HB.

???? im putting my vote on my strongest scumspect who has literally claimed scum or 3rd party
what about this is wrong for you, i was right
ive earned the right to be a little smarmy about it

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

I dont like the vote from HB.

The good news is my previous crackpot theory about HB being directed toward Plum is now back on the menu! (if Plum is a third party)

HanOfTheNekos posted...

It's seeming like Scum cfwr and trying to toss out that there is a Cult, which iirc he did hint at earlier in the day, though the way he did it was in a "oh, what if there is a Cult" manner.

Why would he toss that out if his role couldn't be outted in finding said cult. It puts a big target on him.

Hbthebattle posted...

???? im putting my vote on my strongest scumspect who has literally claimed scum or 3rd party
what about this is wrong for you, i was right
ive earned the right to be a little smarmy about it

I also don't like this response.

Lopen posted...

That's it? That's pitiful. The plum I respect as a strong mafia player (as town) wouldn't abort his suspicion of JC on just that.

Its such a stupid role. But a role that dies unless it gets cult converted fits the setup extremely well.

its enough of a meta read to completely put on the breaks especially considering part of the suspicion was based on the role being a scum setup to live 3 days

masterplum posted...

Anyways, Im out. Im pretty annoyed which is why I left the first time. Probably would have been better for mental health if I had just never come back but that probably wouldnt have been fair to not give you a punchers chance. Maybe I should have not claimed at all and risked getting insta killed and revealing a flavor scanner. Hard to say.

Well you know its a cult game now, Han isnt acting like town. You should probably kill him.

If it was your goal to convince me you are Town, you really flubbed the delivery there.

HanOfTheNekos posted...

If it was your goal to convince me you are Town, you really flubbed the delivery there.

It wasnt

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

I also don't like this response.

Enough that you think I'm scummier than Plum? Be specific in what's wrong with it, Sultan.

honestly if plum full claimed i think i would be on his side but i can't really understand hiding information from us for the next 15 mins if we're gonna know then anyway

Corrik7 posted...

Why would he toss that out if his role couldn't be outted in finding said cult. It puts a big target on him.

*Think meme*

masterplum posted...

its enough of a meta read to completely put on the breaks especially considering part of the suspicion was based on the role being a scum setup to live 3 days

No your primary reason for suspicion was JC giving up

Corrik7 posted...

Why would he toss that out if his role couldn't be outted in finding said cult. It puts a big target on him.

As Scum? Scum love telling Town about third parties. Or maybe the role specifically interacts with Cult in a way that he wanted to draw their attention.

As Cult? Uhhh getting an early separation based on "Cult would never reveal Cult was in the game"?

Lopen posted...

No your primary reason for suspicion was JC giving up

Mmm, that too

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

We are not lynching death.. corrik

Unfortunately you don't have a say in the matter.

masterplum posted...

Mmm, that too

Lol

masterplum posted...

*Think meme*

I don't need to think. Your ploy of whatever sort is already ruined and you could just tell us now and potentially live.

Corrik7 posted...

Unfortunately you don't have a say in the matter.

I don't know, that "... corrik" at the end really was power play.

Corrik7 posted...

Unfortunately you don't have a say in the matter.

You gladiating Him or something??? How wouldn't I have a say?

Okay but lore-wise the character in question wouldnt join the cult.
The character would just gain the powers of the cultmembers.

Corrik7 posted...

I don't need to think. Your ploy of whatever sort is already ruined and you could just tell us now and potentially live.

Possibly

But probably not