Board 8 > Super Smash Bros. Mafia - Topic 1: The Opening Movie

(+) Yeah! (+)

masterplum posted...

Probably a scum wall by Marth there

Marth didn't really scumwall last game what are we hating here exactly.

So what exactly is the full case on Marth here? That he can't possibly have this many reads in the game since most of those people haven't done anything yet? That its too many words for so early a game and unwarranted at that?

Marth gave me pause with the peaf / marth / sbell interaction, sure but maybe i dont see the scum factor of what he's done after that.

Leafeon13N posted...

Marth didn't really scumwall last game what are we hating here exactly.

I was gonna say, he was scum last game and after re-reading topic 1 i felt he was firmly town. So if people are jibberjabbering over him now, then I feel like we have more likely a town marth.

Hell if there were defining features of marth last game, aside from "played intentionally dumb" it would start with "suspected everyone". At just a quick glance this is far from that.

I mean, the case is pretty darn clear so asking what the case is doesn't make sense. Then you can disagree with it but yeah.

I think me own pause is that I had just called Marth out for the Corrik town read and then he throws himself intentionally into the spotlight by doing the same with several other people, obviously fully knowing he would hear from it. Throwing yourself in the spot is most often not a scum move.

ctesjbuvf posted...

Throwing yourself in the spot is most often not a scum move.

Urge to murder everyone here.

ctesjbuvf posted...

I mean, the case is pretty darn clear so asking what the case is doesn't make sense.

Well considering I had my own reasons to be wary of marth I wanted to get confirmation that everyone is just freaking out over marths willingness to share opinions.

Marths list is obviously bullshit, but I think it's intentional. It's actually leas post that bothers me. Seems like it's taking advantage of an easy angle while also pandering to Chris.

##vote: Lea

see you day 2

Corrik7 posted...

Marths list is obviously bullshit, but I think it's intentional. It's actually leas post that bothers me. Seems like it's taking advantage of an easy angle while also pandering to Chris.

##vote: Lea

see you day 2

I don't hate it.

Generally speaking it is good to have marth explain things since that's just basic good mafia communication, but lea's vote did make me raise an eyebrow.

The Chris part kind of bugged me as well but not enough for a vote. Which is why I asked a question in return but currently no response.

Oh speak of the devil

Eh she is still probably town

Lea's vote is fine. Speaking as if knowing Chris is town made me pause a bit though.

The more ulti talks the better I feel about marth.

Obellisk posted...

The more ulti talks the better I feel about marth.

LMAO

Ulti can you not get modkilled

But he's doing such a good job at making sure it happens.

UltimaterializerX posted...

I was mislynched because SBell is an idiot that didnt bother reading the last day. Not wanting to reread 10 topics, fine. At least read the last 50 posts to see if it was solved.

There is no other reason and its idiotic to say there was.

Hey Ulti, your comments from 11:52 this morning would like to say something to you.

Oh look ulti taking the game personal again great.

Oh and this is almost certainly town ulti but on the line of modkill territory.

UltimaterializerX posted...

should be community-banned.

It's clear where the ban should have stayed Ulti.

This is inappropriate behavior for a Mafia Game and you know it.

Nah what you quoted there is something I specifically added to the rule when I did Tekken mafia, which was clearly where Kirby copied it from before he tweaked it.

I mean it's based on something written like +10 years ago, but I specifically added that lol.

But seriously though, this is getting into a territory we should not be in

Get along boomers or no prune juice for a week.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Oh.

Red is scum 90% of the time he publicly asks for modkills when no rules have been broken. I've actually tracked this in my long term notes. 9 times he's done it as scum, once as town.

I also think red is maybe suspicious

UltimaterializerX posted...

when no rules have been broken

literally called me an idiot for something outside of this mafia game 4 hours ago.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Oh.

Red is scum 90% of the time he publicly asks for modkills when no rules have been broken. I've actually tracked this in my long term notes. 9 times he's done it as scum, once as town.

For one, didn't ask for a modkill. Two, literally had a similar discussion about modkill territory last game but you said nothing because we all know your habit to not actually read the game sometimes.

But seriously, put some thicker skin on if you are going to continue to sign up for mafia.

If I self voted in 3 way would this whole argument have been avoided

UnderUrMattress posted...

If I self voted in 3 way would this whole argument have been avoided

Ulti is still mad about something 2 or 3 games ago. So no.

UltimaterializerX posted...

17 players is probably 5 scum, or 4 with an extra kill.

Marth/Red/Chang/?/ +- ?

I appreciate the extra effort you're putting in the game.

UnderUrMattress posted...

Why are you voting me over one read I've had the entire game? What about the rest of my reads?

Catching up on phone
But this echoes my scum mindset from tekken in spades

@UnderUrMattress do you have a link to a reset town game

4 with ek is underpowered.

It's a massively stronger 4. A 4+1 or a 5.

Leafeon13N posted...

Marth didn't really scumwall last game what are we hating here exactly.

You're right, he just posted thirty times in a row instead. Totally different.

There was another post i saw from red that i disliked but i will need to get back to it later. Sorry, being on mobile and having some things to get done.

But the tldr is that red is misconstruing marth in ways that I'm not fond of.

##vote: red

PeaceFrog posted...

You're right, he just posted thirty times in a row instead. Totally different.

There was another post i saw from red that i disliked but i will need to get back to it later. Sorry, being on mobile and having some things to get done.

But the tldr is that red is misconstruing marth in ways that I'm not fond of.

##vote: red

I don't hate this

Chris I'll get you that link shortly.

Marth why do you sound like Chris at times, did you notice that?

htaeD posted...

Marth why do you sound like Chris at times, did you notice that?

Nope, but I'll take that as a compliment!