Board 8 > Smash Ultimate Mafia Topic 5: Or as others call it Smash Brothers for Switch

(+) Yeah! (+)

You tell him Bat! I said the same thing I was expecting some actual reasoning not a stupid scummy why not answer
---

I think bodyguard being dead is better than the one he is supposed to bodyguard!
---

ScareChan posted...

Terra-enforcer posted...

Plus, someone brought this up already iirc, but a lot of people are overlooking how easy of a fakeclaim jack is. Particularly the "commuter" portion. That in particular was a pretty big red flag as with probably one or two exceptions at best, that's something I'd expect from an actual scum jack/commuter going for an obvious fakeclaim.

You know I'm not new and you know I know this. Hell I was just an actual scum commuter in dande of dragons. I know that commuter doesny look good, but it's one of my actions. If I was bullshitting this as scum I am smarter than coupling 2 of the more scummier claims to make.

Okams razor, I'm telling the truth with my Role, han is caught scum

And even if you don't fully trust me now and think I'm scum then I am literally offering myself up 1 for 1. Town always wins by following onto han here

You can't hide behind the "he's just vanilla" excuse anymore. I already said before how BG for Jack is a pretty bad trade in this scenario. So now we don't win just by lynching Han here. Especially since I'd rather choose correctly the first time so we don't have to waste another day lynching the leftover scum player.

Han is likewise trading himself 1 for 1 by essentially conceding to you. There are better routes he could have taken if he was scum who truly wanted a fighting chance. Claiming a BG who didn't move is definitely not that.
---

In fairness to Han, if he used bodyguard on Chris and died we would not have known that's what happened and would have assumed scum killed Han.

Han was tried to lynch Chris are end of day. I wouldn't see that and then the next morning assumed Han saved Chris.

It might even have been enough to mislynch Chris over. Except for the fact that he could have claimed his shot on red, but that's not something bothering bodyguard Han could have predicted.
---

If Chris was scum, there would be no risk into BGing him. In fact, it could prove that Chris was never shot at if neither end up dead.
---

Bodyguard Han could also not have predicted that Chris was a power with just 1 shot.
---

Also If I recall correctly wasnt it han trying to pressure me into trying to lynch Chris? Then when I told him no he got prissy and jumped to lynch other town person jedi?
---

I ask again tho

does a BG stop an assassin or strongman?
---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Also If I recall correctly wasnt it han trying to pressure me into trying to lynch Chris? Then when I told him no he got prissy and jumped to lynch other town person jedi?

You dont remember correctly
---

htaeD posted...

I ask again tho

does a BG stop an assassin or strongman?

Usually not. They go around, or through.
---

Hbthebattle posted...

Han its basically impossible for both of you not to be scum

If you are town, Scare is scum.
If you are scum, Scare is town (probably).

I can think of some possibilities.

Framer. Character who disguises themselves as another player. Possessor.
---

Just to be clear, none of those are standard roles at all. I'm not suggesting they're likely. But that's some thoughts.
---

@UltimaterializerX
@eaedwards6400

We're on page 10 and stuff.
---

Forceful_Dragon posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Really, it's just that you're being so close-minded that I cant help but think you're Scum.

Why do you keep saying this? I have never once said that scare is definitely town and you are definitely scare.

you are definitely scare

I cant believe Scare has been using an alt to accuse himself. Thats like, 10 dimensional chess right there.

Jokes aside, Im catching up on the topic before going to play the new Kirby DLC. Ill still check in regularly of course
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Also If I recall correctly wasnt it han trying to pressure me into trying to lynch Chris? Then when I told him no he got prissy and jumped to lynch other town person jedi?

You dont remember correctly

I guess ill have to go find it...
---

Anyway Shonen continues to look good, as he claims to want to keep prusuing red even after scare's claim stuff happens.

Wish he posted more though.
---

Why are you throwing out possible theories for town Scare, Han?
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

Han its basically impossible for both of you not to be scum

If you are town, Scare is scum.
If you are scum, Scare is town (probably).

I can think of some possibilities.

Framer. Character who disguises themselves as another player. Possessor.

Another possibility is that this is a bluff and Scare is just gambling on me being Scum. Which doesnt really make sense that hed pick me, but picking Death first was a gamble in the same way.

This is the most likely scenario in which Scare is Town - he backed off Death who claimed info, but is not backing off me because I didnt.
---

Lolo_Guru posted...

Why are you throwing out possible theories for town Scare, Han?

All angles are worth pursuing.

And Lolo, why have you played this game SOLELY by asking questions and offering few, if any, actual thoughts?

All you do is ask ask ask. There's no actual hunting process, there's not much in the way of reads... what have you done this game? Please, remind me.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

Han its basically impossible for both of you not to be scum

If you are town, Scare is scum.
If you are scum, Scare is town (probably).

I can think of some possibilities.

Framer. Character who disguises themselves as another player. Possessor.

Another possibility is that this is a bluff and Scare is just gambling on me being Scum. Which doesnt really make sense that hed pick me, but picking Death first was a gamble in the same way.

This is the most likely scenario in which Scare is Town - he backed off Death who claimed info, but is not backing off me because I didnt.

lol

##Unvote
##Vote: Han
---

Points for Han I coukent refined it but he did say yesterday that he was very sold on red and scare being scum together
---

Less than 30 post left. Let's try not to 500 this one
---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Points for Han I coukent refined it but he did say yesterday that he was very sold on red and scare being scum together

You realize this is pointless when scare would obviously already be scum if Han isnt and vice versa

Also I realize I need to stop treating the redvoters as townish as long as I dont know what scare is.
Even if Scare and red are both scum, red was clearly more sacrificeable
---

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/77255518

New topic
---

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/77255518#2
---

Up 1
---

Up2
---

Up3
---