Board 8 > English Literature Mafia Topic 11: Rising Action

(+) Yeah! (+)

Camarija posted...

So 5tarscream saying they are flavor cop, got Red as Cthulu being alignment indicative, it's just wrong

well A) to my (limited) knowledge good/bad seems reasonably likely so far? And Cthulhu isn't a particularly nice dude right?
also B) Red had already claimed Miss Marple at that point, so whatever the split may or may not be he got caught in a lie
---

Camarija posted...

Tom Bombadil posted...

Camarija posted...

Tom Bombadil posted...

Camarija posted...

Camarija posted...

Please help

Flavor Split :: DEFINITION = ??

Mafia = Evil Flavor

Town = Justice Flavor

??

Beep

boop
(I have no idea what you want)

What does flavor split mean?

Who is town and who is mafia. Like 90% of the time the town will be the good guys from whatever the theme is and the scum will be the bad guys. But not always! I remember one game where the scum were all the purple-eyed characters.

Yes

So 5tarscream saying they are flavor cop, got Red as Cthulu being alignment indicative, it's just wrong

Red said he was miss marple. That's when 5tar had something to object
---

Tom Bombadil posted...

1. No. Chris straight up caught her in that.

What is this referring to btw. Like, what did he "catch" her in?
---

Lopen posted...

Tom Bombadil posted...

Doom the Gyarados if it's on your safelist (which it gives me that vibe)

what.

I am guessing it does not give you that vibe? It's the kinda thing I'd throw in for the lulz at the bottom of the safelist if for some reason I was hosting this theme
---

Lea3Lea posted...

My flavour is not fake, goddammit. Sorry to offend your literary sensibilities when we literally have a bojack horseman character and the letter g as characters.

##Unvote

##Vote: Sbell

The Mzero lynch is only feeble because I have -5 reputation this game, but sure, I'll compromise. Sbell prolly scum too

The JD Salinger thing I just ignored the Bojack part. It still fit english lit stuff. I did not read Chris' flavor at all. The likelihood of your claim being fake has gone way down now.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

And Lolo was managing to play even LESS than both Mzero and Sbell day 1. Dont think he posted at all day 1? Except to say he was reading maybe? Feel he absolutely would have been replaced if he was scum.

Thus town (Now this is a kind of meta I like)

Metaing my slot based on replacing or not replacing out is terrible, terrible meta.
---

Lopen posted...

Tom Bombadil posted...

1. No. Chris straight up caught her in that.

What is this referring to btw. Like, what did he "catch" her in?

Han never read Doom, according to Chris. I admit the possibility he threw it in anyway as a mindscrew but I don't think it's a great one.
---

Lolo_Guru posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

And Lolo was managing to play even LESS than both Mzero and Sbell day 1. Dont think he posted at all day 1? Except to say he was reading maybe? Feel he absolutely would have been replaced if he was scum.

Thus town (Now this is a kind of meta I like)

Metaing my slot based on replacing or not replacing out is terrible, terrible meta.

But I'm right, am I not?
---

I didnt say you'd have replaced out. I said you'd have been replaced.
---

Alright, in fairness I admit that faking something like that is 100% something I would do because it would be hilarious and audacious and ultimately work, and something I used to have a reputation for but THIS TIME IT'S REAL, DAMN IT.

I think my record this game has been relatively decent. I've suspected scum, but incompetently, which as you can see gains me no benefit as scum for bussing and pretending to be town hero and neither does it help scummates lay low. I like to think I've been a positive factor in the game - Chris shot Luis partially because he noticed he was soft defending him.....from me. I just have an annoying attitude one might describe as overly honest and a little careless.

If I was gonna meta Lolo not being replaced I'd actually think that'd make him more likely to be scum? Like he's deliberately lying low but active enough in scumchat to show himself engaged with the game
---

Well the point is I soul read him town and I'm back to making up some bullshit to confirm him.
---

Tom Bombadil posted...

Lopen posted...

Tom Bombadil posted...

Doom the Gyarados if it's on your safelist (which it gives me that vibe)

what.

I am guessing it does not give you that vibe? It's the kinda thing I'd throw in for the lulz at the bottom of the safelist if for some reason I was hosting this theme

Tom Bombadil posted...

Lopen posted...

Tom Bombadil posted...

1. No. Chris straight up caught her in that.

What is this referring to btw. Like, what did he "catch" her in?

Han never read Doom, according to Chris. I admit the possibility he threw it in anyway as a mindscrew but I don't think it's a great one.

How do these two thoughts live in harmony in your brain.
---

Calling my flavour safe listy is EXACTLY what sbell said

Newsflash if Han actually hadn't read the Doom story why would it be on the safelist anyway Tom?

pretty easily

if I didn't have familiarity with a character I probably wouldn't make them a role in my game but I might throw them on the safelist as a joke
---

Or is it the other way around that I'm trying to defend my dirty game-breaking meta by covering it up with "Oh i soul read him town" ?

You'll never know. Except that one of those avenues points to him being town and me being right.
---

Chris's reason for calling Lolo for having his sole post be a defense of Red in votestuffer land is reasonable to buy for now anyway

especially after DoomTheGyarados got on the playerlist
---

Lea3Lea posted...

Alright, in fairness I admit that faking something like that is 100% something I would do because it would be hilarious and audacious and ultimately work, and something I used to have a reputation for but THIS TIME IT'S REAL, DAMN IT.

I think my record this game has been relatively decent. I've suspected scum, but incompetently, which as you can see gains me no benefit as scum for bussing and pretending to be town hero and neither does it help scummates lay low. I like to think I've been a positive factor in the game - Chris shot Luis partially because he noticed he was soft defending him.....from me. I just have an annoying attitude one might describe as overly honest and a little careless.

I just assumed it was fake and meant to be known it was fake. I did not assume it was on a safelist or actually a real flavor. Now that you're doubling down and saying it's really your real flavor, I agree with you and Lopen that it's a town tell.
---

y'all are weird
---

I think they live in harmony in your brain because your brain is fabricated.
---

Someone vote this guy look at this contradictory thought process.
---

well there's a shock
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Lolo_Guru posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

And Lolo was managing to play even LESS than both Mzero and Sbell day 1. Dont think he posted at all day 1? Except to say he was reading maybe? Feel he absolutely would have been replaced if he was scum.

Thus town (Now this is a kind of meta I like)

Metaing my slot based on replacing or not replacing out is terrible, terrible meta.

But I'm right, am I not?

Replacing out is nearly always based on out-of-game reasons, not in-game ones.
You are incorrect, I definitely posted day 1. Sbell did more than me (had a decent argument with him), but I possibly did more than Mzero, not completely sure.

Chris and Chris alone gets the credit for confirming me town. You get no credit for it whatsoever. No offense!
---

A safelist that instantly gets scum lynched for it being a stretch or a joke doesn't sound very safe to me all I'm saying

It would have been so sweet if it was fake and got Chris not to shoot me though. I'd finally have something worth bragging about this game!

Lynch this list and we win

Mzero
Sbell
Tom
Pez
Death

Han I want you to pin that in the scum Discord so that they can see the countdown to their obliteration.
---

"Watertight fake claims"

"Miss Marple"

"Flavor Scanner"

:doubt:

Lopen posted...

Tom Bombadil posted...

Lopen posted...

Tom Bombadil posted...

Doom the Gyarados if it's on your safelist (which it gives me that vibe)

what.

I am guessing it does not give you that vibe? It's the kinda thing I'd throw in for the lulz at the bottom of the safelist if for some reason I was hosting this theme

Tom Bombadil posted...

Lopen posted...

Tom Bombadil posted...

1. No. Chris straight up caught her in that.

What is this referring to btw. Like, what did he "catch" her in?

Han never read Doom, according to Chris. I admit the possibility he threw it in anyway as a mindscrew but I don't think it's a great one.

How do these two thoughts live in harmony in your brain.

Just because Han didn't read Doom, didn't mean he wasn't aware it existed.
---

That's not neccisarily the right order though. For example, Pez before Tom every time
---

UltimaterializerX posted...

Chris's most recent town list is gospel as far as I'm concerned. The only one of those players I would remotely consider killing is Pez, but that isn't happening today and I acknowledge my read there could be wrong.

Someone asked if Pez town Tom scum was possible. I think it might be.

I didnt ask. I said it's IMPOSSIBLE
---

Honestly though even putting that aside

Doom just isn't something you'd bother to put on a safelist is the thing

It's like when I fakeclaimed Angeal Hewley when I was SK in FFVII mafia. I knew that guy was not in the game and my fakeclaim list was junk, so I just blind claimed it, and of course random significant Crisis Core character was not in the game.
---

Lea3Lea posted...

A safelist that instantly gets scum lynched for it being a stretch or a joke doesn't sound very safe to me all I'm saying

you sure did get instantly lynched for claiming that by kingmaker DoomTheGyarados

also do you remember the part where I said it would be a joke
---

Lolo_Guru posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Lolo_Guru posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

And Lolo was managing to play even LESS than both Mzero and Sbell day 1. Dont think he posted at all day 1? Except to say he was reading maybe? Feel he absolutely would have been replaced if he was scum.

Thus town (Now this is a kind of meta I like)

Metaing my slot based on replacing or not replacing out is terrible, terrible meta.

But I'm right, am I not?

Replacing out is nearly always based on out-of-game reasons, not in-game ones.
You are incorrect, I definitely posted day 1. Sbell did more than me (had a decent argument with him), but I possibly did more than Mzero, not completely sure.

Chris and Chris alone gets the credit for confirming me town. You get no credit for it whatsoever. No offense!

Haha. That's okay. I dont need the credit. I'm just trying to protect you
---

Ok

I'm forgetting these dumb fake claims

Im going to reread tomorrow with fresh mindset

Only Mafia

Camarija posted...

"Miss Marple"

what is wrong with that being on the safelist

what does flavor scanner have to do with anything

UltimaterializerX posted...

Hey Tom I'm going to sleep.

Apparently I need to announce these things! :D

you seem to have missed the part where I saw your announcements and ignored them because you are known to lie about out of game stuff
---

Lopen posted...

Doom just isn't something you'd bother to put on a safelist is the thing

so are you proposing that it is something that you'd bother to put in the actual game, or that it's a randoclaim that Lea doubled down on afterwards?

setting aside that it's something I'd bother to put on a safelist and suspect Han could as well
---

randoclaim double down yea
---

and it doesn't concern you that Lea is lying and continues to do so in that case?
---

Not particularly. I think late game if no dramatic revelation has come from her she's an easy lynch.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Lolo_Guru posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Lolo_Guru posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

And Lolo was managing to play even LESS than both Mzero and Sbell day 1. Dont think he posted at all day 1? Except to say he was reading maybe? Feel he absolutely would have been replaced if he was scum.

Thus town (Now this is a kind of meta I like)

Metaing my slot based on replacing or not replacing out is terrible, terrible meta.

But I'm right, am I not?

Replacing out is nearly always based on out-of-game reasons, not in-game ones.
You are incorrect, I definitely posted day 1. Sbell did more than me (had a decent argument with him), but I possibly did more than Mzero, not completely sure.

Chris and Chris alone gets the credit for confirming me town. You get no credit for it whatsoever. No offense!

Haha. That's okay. I dont need the credit. I'm just trying to protect you

Why.
---

I think the flavor talk is a waste of time and if she's town you're only letting scum have an easy lynch by voting based off the flavor and not the content
---

UltimaterializerX posted...

Tom Bombadil posted...

Camarija posted...

"Miss Marple"

what is wrong with that being on the safelist

what does flavor scanner have to do with anything

UltimaterializerX posted...

Hey Tom I'm going to sleep.

Apparently I need to announce these things! :D

you seem to have missed the part where I saw your announcements and ignored them because you are known to lie about out of game stuff

You might want to read the bolded parts of the opening post. My options are play strictly by the rules or I don't get to play here. We're at that point.

I don't see a rule forbidding lying about out of game stuff!

(I do actually believe you're going to sleep but you don't get a free pass for whatever it was you said you were missing a chunk of time for)
---

why do people keep talking about all of my suspects being easy lynches and they're all very comfortably still here

(except Chris)
---

Lolo_Guru posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Lolo_Guru posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Lolo_Guru posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

And Lolo was managing to play even LESS than both Mzero and Sbell day 1. Dont think he posted at all day 1? Except to say he was reading maybe? Feel he absolutely would have been replaced if he was scum.

Thus town (Now this is a kind of meta I like)

Metaing my slot based on replacing or not replacing out is terrible, terrible meta.

But I'm right, am I not?

Replacing out is nearly always based on out-of-game reasons, not in-game ones.
You are incorrect, I definitely posted day 1. Sbell did more than me (had a decent argument with him), but I possibly did more than Mzero, not completely sure.

Chris and Chris alone gets the credit for confirming me town. You get no credit for it whatsoever. No offense!

Haha. That's okay. I dont need the credit. I'm just trying to protect you

Why.

To get you on my good side and pocket your vote of course.

Nah, I already posted my scum list. I'm committed. My pride is on the line.

Anyone else is town and will be treated as such

...your highness.
---

It's a waste of time as content in and of itself. I was discussing it to see if Tom's logic on it made sense to me as internally consistent. Much like other topics it does not.

I do think that Lea being something that will "resolve itself" is actually content people who will survive that long should take note of. For me she's an obvious late game lynch if she is still claiming to be Doom then.
---