Board 8 > Sir Chris Music Mafia 5: Play that song....all night looong!

(+) Yeah! (+)

Panthera posted...

PJ, how do you feel about Puns claiming miller after you instead of doing the first post claim routine like you did?

Zam is probably town here.

Is Corrik even playing? Because it sure doesn't feel like it

Poor look for panth again
---

So coming into today I did not like Sultan, Crescent, Red, Panth

and looking over the Zam iso it just strentgens that

like that may be the other 4 right there
---

Crescent-Moon posted...

Ooh I got votes

Curiously neither of them so much as either commented on anything I had actually said and focused on the most trivial sentence.

Scare conjuring up a reason to vote me while ignoring my content is a pretty big red flag

See Scare I can do it too~

oh yeah I forgot crescent came at me with an attitude too. This post in paticular felt a lot like ruffled scum
---

ScareChan posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

ScareChan posted...

Well now that panth is not lynched

I think the 'correct' move is to let him live today

eaed does NOT jailkeep him and we force him to mason

if no one claims mason tomorrow or if he claims he masons the dead guy then we auto lynch

The only problem I have with this is if he masons scum and they dont step forward, and less concerning if he "masons" a scumbud.

missed this

he said he dies trying to recruit scum

and his only option is recruit tony

Ok I missed that part of the claim. And him linking with a scumbud is a bad play then because you cant not kill masons.
---

oh my god its 4am
---

Crescent-Moon posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

ColZach posted...

turbopuns2 posted...

ColZach posted...

Someone asked me why not lynch plum

Because the counter question of why SHOULD we lynch plum?

Ive been a part of 3 day 1s now and IIRC the only time we lynched scum day 1 was when Chris had 3 votes on poor unwim

So....why not lynch plum?

This argument is the same as why not lynch anyone? Lets just RNG it, 6/22 chance to lynch scum right?

Tbh Im at work like I said earlier so if plum has been showing apathy I need to catch up on it on my reread

Also I have more to learn about mafia because this idea of no lynch being strictly anti town seems blatantly wrong and incorrect.

ColZach posted...

Hey guys. Been a busy day and I have more work tonight but heres my thoughts after my initial read

1. Dont lynch plum.
2. Id lynch Leo.
3. Im still independent DJ.

So why lynch Leo but not Plum? Specifically NOT Plum?

I second this question

---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

ScareChan posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

ScareChan posted...

Well now that panth is not lynched

I think the 'correct' move is to let him live today

eaed does NOT jailkeep him and we force him to mason

if no one claims mason tomorrow or if he claims he masons the dead guy then we auto lynch

The only problem I have with this is if he masons scum and they dont step forward, and less concerning if he "masons" a scumbud.

missed this

he said he dies trying to recruit scum

and his only option is recruit tony

Ok I missed that part of the claim. And him linking with a scumbud is a bad play then because you cant not kill masons.

hey I wanted to ask how you are doing by the way bro
---

ScareChan posted...

Alakazamtrainer posted...

some thoughts at the end of page 3

I like Panthera a lot here, he's pushing convo on day 1. I also like death, despite him making a mountain out of a molehill.

I dislike the plum train, and the Leo counter train, I don't think either are going anywhere to be honest.

(end of page 3)

I think this looks poor on Panth again

I dunno. Considering what he said about me, it could be Zam trying to fight his accusers with 'friendship and accolades'. Then again I dont recall if Panth accused Zam of anything.
---

No it looks clear that zam tried to buddy you especially considering he even called himself scum to make you like him. Liking panth for just posting is pretty fluffy itself even when taking a stance
---

Fair enough.

I might as well do my own personal ISO. Just dont expect quotewalls.
---

I trimming the fat best I can but posting things that catch my eye
---

And honestly I'm on mobile now and should sleep anyways
---

ScareChan posted...

also IGCD I know (or assume) you have been busy and all bbut I feel you have been not very present lately

tell me where your thoughts lie right now

Complacency and paranoia, the usual when town is killing it. I'm unsure why Rik thought Sultan is scum if Panth is town. I agree that we are in a place where we can kill inactives if they dont start providing content. I know I have just been lurking and it looks bad, but like I said there really hasn't been much for me to do since both days were set lynches from when I joined/start of day 2.

I had more that I wanted to say but lost my train of though because I started this post 2 hours ago.
---

For the record. I dont immediately see how Zam would ask which miller was a counterclaim, if he knew one of was false already.

Thats the only thing in pj's favor so far.
---

htaeD posted...

ScareChan posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

ScareChan posted...

Well now that panth is not lynched

I think the 'correct' move is to let him live today

eaed does NOT jailkeep him and we force him to mason

if no one claims mason tomorrow or if he claims he masons the dead guy then we auto lynch

The only problem I have with this is if he masons scum and they dont step forward, and less concerning if he "masons" a scumbud.

missed this

he said he dies trying to recruit scum

and his only option is recruit tony

a recruiter dying by recruiting scum still helps us. but the resulting info can be muddied by scum just shooting him.

That's actually not that bad because it forces them to leave protection alive.
---

If you want to mislynch me fine go for it. You are reading way to much into me asking if it was possible to have more then 1 of the same role when people claimed the role. Then someone actually answered my question saying yes it was possible and with a jack it's even more possible to have 2 of the same because how the jack works.

So scare o think you are reading into it a little to much and my comments about leo and corrik was a really bad hunch because I thought Leo was scum all day and he kept saying oh whatever corrik thinks so yes it did make me a little weary about corrik. And I was going to stay on Leo all day and that's why I was hesitant to vote panthe and end they but you f**** wherent going to to change your mind and vote leo who I'm glad gor lawyered because that's who i thought was scum more then panthe. But I got tired of reading its panth its panth we arent changing out minds its panth so I was like okay looks like we arent getting anything else out of the day let's just end it. It was probably a rookie mistake to waste 24 hours but you guys where so stuck we would have waited the 24 hours and got the same result.

Sorry for the rant but apparently I look so bad I might as well explain before scare gets me mislynched
---

I think Sultan is town
---

@Forceful_Dragon

Would you have died if leo was town

Also red calling me inactive is stupid I was active almost all day yesterday...
---

ScareChan posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

ScareChan posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

ScareChan posted...

Well now that panth is not lynched

I think the 'correct' move is to let him live today

eaed does NOT jailkeep him and we force him to mason

if no one claims mason tomorrow or if he claims he masons the dead guy then we auto lynch

The only problem I have with this is if he masons scum and they dont step forward, and less concerning if he "masons" a scumbud.

missed this

he said he dies trying to recruit scum

and his only option is recruit tony

Ok I missed that part of the claim. And him linking with a scumbud is a bad play then because you cant not kill masons.

hey I wanted to ask how you are doing by the way bro

A lot better than I have been, I dont want it to distract from the game but my depression hit a point where I attempted suicide the day before tiny toons started, that was the reason for my replace and the reason I was a tentative for this game. My work is actually the reason I sought help and am now on proper medication. So I am 1000xs better than I have been for a long time.
---

Can you claim for me sultan
---

turbopuns2 posted...

@Forceful_Dragon

Would you have died if leo was town

He said yes I believe
---

Happy to hear you are working through it igcd
---

Oh

ScareChan posted...

Happy to hear you are working through it igcd

Thanks, now dont take it easy on me. I need confrontation to get me going.
---

Scare won vote isnt going to make me claim I'll claim on my own terms sir.
---

It's why I always liked playing with @Terra-enforcer he always butted heads with me and it forced me to get involved.
---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Scare won vote isnt going to make me claim I'll claim on my own terms sir.

##Vote:Sultan
---

##vote: Sultan

Sultan, in lieu of a vote I will just say.
If you are that terrified of being mislynched, you might as well claim.
---

How about now
---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

ScareChan posted...

Happy to hear you are working through it igcd

Thanks, now dont take it easy on me. I need confrontation to get me going.

Oh I will still rko the shit out of you

But it's got to be out of nowhere
---

ScareChan posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

ScareChan posted...

Happy to hear you are working through it igcd

Thanks, now dont take it easy on me. I need confrontation to get me going.

Oh I will still rko the shit out of you

But it's got to be out of nowhere

I wouldnt have it any other way.
---

htaeD posted...

Sultan, in lieu of a vote I will just say.
If you are that terrified of being mislynched, you might as well claim.

ScareChan posted...

How about now

Fine you guys are good...

Forceful_Dragon posted...

Unless Sultan knows about the existence of other town protection that the rest of us are unaware of...

Yes fd I am aware of another town protection and that is me

I am a sing Chris really enjoys

Also why I kept asking if it was possible to have the same role twice... if it wasn't I would have claimed yesterday.

Well either way I'm going to probably die today in a mislynch or in the night phase so I guess I'll just say It...

I am sultan of slam and I am the bodyguard
---

htaeD posted...

For the record. I dont immediately see how Zam would ask which miller was a counterclaim, if he knew one of was false already.

Thats the only thing in pj's favor so far.

I like this post.

Although I'm pretty sure Zam was asking me specifically (even though he didn't mention me by name in the post) if I was countering.

I still think it's a good point though, and award you with 2 town points

Well then

That's about the fastest a town read has evaporated

But does Sultan really have the bravado to claim BG there? Hmmmm
---

Current Votals (Last vote #279)

[3] - Sultan - Scare, IGCD, puns
[2] - Panth - Tony, Zach

With 18 alive it takes 10 to lynch. Day ends 11:00 PM EDT on Friday.

---

.....

Sultan should be better at fakeclaiming by now, shouldnt he?

Uhm...
Ehr.. what were your actions?
---

What even happens to a BG that guards a BG?
---

htaeD posted...

.....

Sultan should be better at fakeclaiming by now, shouldnt he?

Uhm...
Ehr.. what were your actions?

This is only his second game so I don't see why he would be much better
---

htaeD posted...

.....

Sultan should be better at fakeclaiming by now, shouldnt he?

Uhm...
Ehr.. what were your actions?

htaeD posted...

.....

Sultan should be better at fakeclaiming by now, shouldnt he?

Uhm...
Ehr.. what were your actions?

Am i aloud to say it can't you get modkilled explaining it to much?
---

You can say who you bodyguarded each night, yes.
Not how (thats self-evident anyway, isnt it?), just who.
---

And I mean in the sense of 'claiming a role that already died!'
I am not asking for a more detailed claim.
---

Night 1. Panthe
Night 2. FD
---

BTw PJ, when you get back here its really important that you tell us if you are actually a miller.
---

...........
Panthera?
---

htaeD posted...

...........
Panthera?

Yes
---

Also I would have protected Tony/Corrik or Eaed night2 as well. But thats less of an oversight to me.
---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

htaeD posted...

...........
Panthera?

Yes

Why?
---

Immediate future plan thoughts

Have Sultan BG Panth, who recruits someone we designate, while Tony watches one of the two.
RB and scumkill cant cover all angles there.

Then again, its probably too good to be true.
---