Board 8 > English Literature Mafia Topic 1: Once Upon a Time

(+) Yeah! (+)

Tom Bombadil posted...

and you're already off it anyway

Am I? Am I?
---

pezloco posted...

Tom Bombadil posted...
I skimmed up until nowish but while I re-read more thoroughly it's time for discussion questions

1. Pezloco: who is scum
- - It's day 1. I'm withholding judgment on a lot of players. But I have a good town feeling about one player in particular. I'll say more D2 if it's necessary at that point.

We all know it's me, you don't have to hide it!
---

Votals (as of post #200)

(2) No Lynch: pezloco, Tom, (Lopen)
(1) MZero: Lea
(1) Puns: (Lea), Corrik, (Ulti)
(1) Ulti: (Lopen), Hb
(1) Lopen: Ulti

---

What do people think about Mzero?

Corrik.

Do you think I'm scum?

Corrik7 told me he's Asian. I think Corrik7 was only half right but I digress.
---

Lying town doesn't necessarily always hurt town.

So is he scum or town Corrik.
---

turbopuns3 posted...

Corrik.

Do you think I'm scum?

I will assess that when you claim your actual role and your behavior today. As of now, all I know is that you are lying.
---

Eh, just Pun's responses to everyone's distrust about him being Miller are really honest. He clearly doesn't like that he's Miller. And he clearly is that which he doesn't like. HE'S TOWN
---

Lopen posted...

Gonna be honest I don't quite follow the logic of why breadcrumbing power making scum less likely to shoot you makes claiming miller a good idea

At least I think that's what he said

Someone (you?) asked him why he didn't try to draw scum's shot since he's a miller.

I think he said that's why he didn't try to draw the shot/attention. He tried that last game and it didn't work. So he's not going to try that this time. So that's a reason to not not claim
---

Lopen posted...

Corrik7 told me he's Asian. I think Corrik7 was only half right but I digress.

Mzero is Asian. 5tar is American who lives in Asia.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Eh, just Pun's responses to everyone's distrust about him being Miller are really honest. He clearly doesn't like that he's Miller. And he clearly is that which he doesn't like. HE'S TOWN

You called him confirmed town based on his first post, before he did any of that

benjamin3740 posted...

Eh, just Pun's responses to everyone's distrust about him being Miller are really honest. He clearly doesn't like that he's Miller. And he clearly is that which he doesn't like. HE'S TOWN

The fact he is not miller means this is not a correct read.
---

Corrik7 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Corrik7 posted...

There are no Millers this game however so maybe we can just not waste time and lynch puns now.

So do you think he's scum if he's lying?

It is irrelevant. He is lying. It has been outted he is lying. He needs to actually claim now, and it can be assessed from there. You don't get to fake claim to the game and get away without claiming. By policy, he is to be lynched if he doesn't reclaim his actual role and I expect much support with votes regarding this.

As scum or town, he dies today without claiming his actual role. He doesn't get away with that fake claim today.

Or we could not focus our day trying to pull claims out of people.
---

Lea3Lea posted...

What do people think about Mzero?

I think he plays super nonchalant. Example - last game in the final 3. I didn't read all of last game, but did watch final 3.

Which is annoying to me because I can't read him easily. It usually takes... awhile. I'll just ignore him most of the game until something obvious happens.
---

Corrik7 posted...

turbopuns3 posted...

Corrik.

Do you think I'm scum?

I will assess that when you claim your actual role and your behavior today. As of now, all I know is that you are lying.

Ok you're not on my scum list but I'm disregarding you for the time being.

Lea3Lea posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Eh, just Pun's responses to everyone's distrust about him being Miller are really honest. He clearly doesn't like that he's Miller. And he clearly is that which he doesn't like. HE'S TOWN

You called him confirmed town based on his first post, before he did any of that

I did. Then his follow ups solidified it further for me telling me it's not just a really good prepared pre-game first, and I'm probably not a hack, and I may need to slam down a certain OFFICIAL book that isn't exactly fine English literature but is definitely in English
---

*first post
---

I didn't ask him that. If I was a miller I know I certainly wouldn't want to draw shots. My elite skills are more valuable than cop scans.
---

Lopen posted...

I didn't ask him that. If I was a miller I know I certainly wouldn't want to draw shots. My elite skills are more valuable than cop scans.

Maybe it was @Lea3Lea? Anyway, my point stands. His comment about breadcrumbing power was a reference to how he played last game as nilla. Not his reasoning for claiming miller this game, at least not his whole reasoning.
---

pezloco posted...

Corrik7 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Corrik7 posted...

There are no Millers this game however so maybe we can just not waste time and lynch puns now.

So do you think he's scum if he's lying?

It is irrelevant. He is lying. It has been outted he is lying. He needs to actually claim now, and it can be assessed from there. You don't get to fake claim to the game and get away without claiming. By policy, he is to be lynched if he doesn't reclaim his actual role and I expect much support with votes regarding this.

As scum or town, he dies today without claiming his actual role. He doesn't get away with that fake claim today.

Or we could not focus our day trying to pull claims out of people.

He has already "claimed" and it is already outted he fakeclaimed. Which narrows it down what he is while also shedding light onto me for revealing he is lying.

He needs to fully claim as scum has no issue with faking that role and his faking does not in any way make him town.
---

Lea3Lea posted...

MZero11 posted...

Lea3Lea posted...

To wit, Mzero asked a question to someone and didn't follow up which implies he didn't actually care about the answer, and isn't really commenting aside answering my question by not commenting on Puns. Like obviously there aren't many posts, but you can still have some thought on how Puns claimed beyond parroting the party line about judging on play not the claim.

I mean, there wasn't really anything to follow up with. Ulti admitted it wasn't the best idea. I'm not going to beat the dead horse over it

I had no issue with Puns' claim

Then what was the point of asking?

You don't have an issue with the way he claimed because _______ ?

Because rhetorical questions are a completely natural thing that people do

Because I don't have an issue with it? What kind of question is that

you're nitpicking that silliest stuff right now
---

Corrik7 posted...

Camarija, are you Vanilla Townie?

lmfao, yeah I'm not making the same mistake twice

I go by Town Vanilla, Town Villager, or whatever the heck you call it these days ;)

@Corrik7

Or yeah, maybe not?

My flavor is disconcerting to me and makes me feel odd

Right. To my knowledge he never said why he claimed miller other than joke answers and stuff that doesn't explain how it helps town
---

Does this forum have lost wolves?

Corrik7 posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Eh, just Pun's responses to everyone's distrust about him being Miller are really honest. He clearly doesn't like that he's Miller. And he clearly is that which he doesn't like. HE'S TOWN

The fact he is not miller means this is not a correct read.

My read on Puns>>>FF8 Remastered>>>>>>>>>>>>>Your baseless statememt that implies too much information
---

MZero11 posted...

Lea3Lea posted...

MZero11 posted...

Lea3Lea posted...

To wit, Mzero asked a question to someone and didn't follow up which implies he didn't actually care about the answer, and isn't really commenting aside answering my question by not commenting on Puns. Like obviously there aren't many posts, but you can still have some thought on how Puns claimed beyond parroting the party line about judging on play not the claim.

I mean, there wasn't really anything to follow up with. Ulti admitted it wasn't the best idea. I'm not going to beat the dead horse over it

I had no issue with Puns' claim

Then what was the point of asking?

You don't have an issue with the way he claimed because _______ ?

Because rhetorical questions are a completely natural thing that people do

Because I don't have an issue with it? What kind of question is that

you're nitpicking that silliest stuff right now

And you're apparently posting just to hear yourself type instead of scum hunting. Like, not even the slightest little bit of trying to figure out Ulti's alignment based on that? Literally just asking rhetorical questions

Camarija posted...

Does this forum have lost wolves?

Not very often
---

Page 7 and dudes still talking about Puns miller claim

lol

Is there anything worth reading then?

Also Hi, I'm Camarija

I'm Town Opera Singer

Each night I can sing opera

Corrik7 posted...

As scum or town, he dies today without claiming his actual role. He doesn't get away with that fake claim today.

wait what.
---

Camarija posted...

Corrik7 posted...

Camarija, are you Vanilla Townie?

lmfao, yeah I'm not making the same mistake twice

I go by Town Vanilla, Town Villager, or whatever the heck you call it these days ;)

@Corrik7

Or yeah, maybe not?

My flavor is disconcerting to me and makes me feel odd

Why did you just post this?

Lea3Lea posted...

And you're apparently posting just to hear yourself type instead of scum hunting.

This is what I've been doing with 93% of my posts

Luckily I've been spamming posts so there was probably something useful in there
---

Lea3Lea posted...

MZero11 posted...

Lea3Lea posted...

MZero11 posted...

Lea3Lea posted...

To wit, Mzero asked a question to someone and didn't follow up which implies he didn't actually care about the answer, and isn't really commenting aside answering my question by not commenting on Puns. Like obviously there aren't many posts, but you can still have some thought on how Puns claimed beyond parroting the party line about judging on play not the claim.

I mean, there wasn't really anything to follow up with. Ulti admitted it wasn't the best idea. I'm not going to beat the dead horse over it

I had no issue with Puns' claim

Then what was the point of asking?

You don't have an issue with the way he claimed because _______ ?

Because rhetorical questions are a completely natural thing that people do

Because I don't have an issue with it? What kind of question is that

you're nitpicking that silliest stuff right now

And you're apparently posting just to hear yourself type instead of scum hunting. Like, not even the slightest little bit of trying to figure out Ulti's alignment based on that? Literally just asking rhetorical questions

If that's your assertion of whoever you're talking about

I think whoever you're talking about is likely to be villager rather than mafia

MZero11 = Town

^10 posts per page. Oh sweet summer child.
---

Lopen posted...

Lea3Lea posted...

And you're apparently posting just to hear yourself type instead of scum hunting.

This is what I've been doing with 93% of my posts

Luckily I've been spamming posts so there was probably something useful in there

Yours are pretty funny tho so I'll make an exception

Lea3Lea posted...

Camarija posted...

Corrik7 posted...

Camarija, are you Vanilla Townie?

lmfao, yeah I'm not making the same mistake twice

I go by Town Vanilla, Town Villager, or whatever the heck you call it these days ;)

@Corrik7

Or yeah, maybe not?

My flavor is disconcerting to me and makes me feel odd

Why did you just post this?

Ask a pointed question and I will answer

I posted this because I'm playing a game of mafia ya goof

Camarija posted...

Page 7 and dudes still talking about Puns miller claim

lol

Is there anything worth reading then?

Also Hi, I'm Camarija

I'm Town Opera Singer

Each night I can sing opera

Aww. I want that role
---

Lopen posted...

Right. To my knowledge he never said why he claimed miller other than joke answers and stuff that doesn't explain how it helps town

For fucks sake literally one game ago I rolled town vanilla, tried to draw scum's ire and I ended up being the "town they had no interest in messing with"

And here I literally scan guilty why do you think I wouldn't claim as such when that's the accepted play for miller on B8 since forever

Lea3Lea posted...

Unnecessary checking in post from new guy

5tar isn't particularly new! (oh boy do we get to debate the semantics of this statement for five pages again)

turbopuns3 posted...

mox

wwe mafia was last game and there wasn't any AEW in it

In a shocking twist I am not inclined to participate in all the delicious king james FLAVOR META~~~ because I am not educated well enough to participate with this flavor

pezloco posted...

anti-town

translation before pez gets lynched: bad town

Corrik7 posted...

Thanks Tom for a list of a bunch of questions, half of which don't pertain to this game of mafia. Seems like real Town behavior there.

thanks for answer tune in next time when I catch you on a capitalization slip

benjamin3740 posted...

Why'd you feel the need to ask EVERYONE a question?

And im not really sure what kind of answer you want from me. Im not new to mafia if that's what you're interested in

Seemed like a fun gimmick! I am mainly interested in what you came up with to say but am also curious about your history and play style and stuff since I don't recognize you;.

Lea3Lea posted...

What do people think about Mzero?

Not much yet- he's quiet and he was last game too and IIRC he's a weird time zone guy. I wanted to lynch him all last game when I was pretending I was town.

Camarija posted...

I go by Town Vanilla, Town Villager, or whatever the heck you call it these days ;)

boy that is an unconvincing opener
---

turbopuns3 posted...

Lopen posted...

Right. To my knowledge he never said why he claimed miller other than joke answers and stuff that doesn't explain how it helps town

For fucks sake literally one game ago I rolled town vanilla, tried to draw scum's ire and I ended up being the "town they had no interest in messing with"

And here I literally scan guilty why do you think I wouldn't claim as such when that's the accepted play for miller on B8 since forever

If you scan guilty, it is because you are scum. You are not a miller.

If ur town, you need to stop this nonsense before I have to claim and end it once and for all.
---

Cool

I thought they were only funny to me

I'm on mobile it's hard to read more than 140 characters at once you know
---

Camarija posted...

Page 7 and dudes still talking about Puns miller claim

lol

Is there anything worth reading then?

Also Hi, I'm Camarija

I'm Town Opera Singer

Each night I can sing opera

What was your immediate reaction to it anyway?
---

Lea3Lea posted...

And you're apparently posting just to hear yourself type instead of scum hunting. Like, not even the slightest little bit of trying to figure out Ulti's alignment based on that? Literally just asking rhetorical questions

if you're going to attack me based on asking a rhetorical question in the first 15 minutes of the game then "ok"
---

Tom Bombadil posted...

thanks for answer tune in next time when I catch you on a capitalization slip

U capitalized miller this game alrdy due to autocorrect. You aren't reading my posts.
---

I*
---

Corrik, just...chill? Please lol you aren't helping a thing

Okay. Puns is town. I see what's up. Carry on.
---

MZero11 posted...

Lea3Lea posted...

And you're apparently posting just to hear yourself type instead of scum hunting. Like, not even the slightest little bit of trying to figure out Ulti's alignment based on that? Literally just asking rhetorical questions

if you're going to attack me based on asking a rhetorical question in the first 15 minutes of the game then "ok"

I mean, it's the start of day one, are you really gonna play the "offended by someone not having an iron clad argument on you" card? I wanted to see how you'd react, or if all your posts would just be answering direct questions I ask, and I'm unimpressed on both counts.

turbopuns3 posted...

And here I literally scan guilty why do you think I wouldn't claim as such when that's the accepted play for miller on B8 since forever

It seems like accepted play for millers who want to be lazy. Not seeing why an elite talent would do it
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Camarija posted...

Page 7 and dudes still talking about Puns miller claim

lol

Is there anything worth reading then?

Also Hi, I'm Camarija

I'm Town Opera Singer

Each night I can sing opera

What was your immediate reaction to it anyway?

That I don't care

It seems to be a common opener in the games I've played here, in my limited memory

I won't touch the claim until something suggests puns actually is Mafia