| Board List | Page List: 1 |
|---|---|
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 5: To Fort Dragonia!! |
| Sheep007 05/16/17 6:01:58 PM #254 | |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 5: To Fort Dragonia!! |
| Sheep007 05/16/17 1:03:26 PM #240 | I dunno how this reminds you of me as Town, Terra, considering this is my first Town game in nearly two years. I've basically completely forgotten how to play competently tbh. I'll probably stick with slower games for a while after this. I did vote D1 Death, voted PJ and left. I'm not sure if God here is Scum trying to get credit assuming I get lynched anyway or completely genuine. He'd still be one of my top lynches rn. Not sure what Ulti is doing, has basically just came in here, called me probable Scum but has done nothing really and kept his vote on Red. Still believe the Miller claim though. No clue what the hell Red's role is but if it's power I can reasonably see him as Town. I mentioned this earlier but someone said he softclaimed Vig before? Never got a reply about that. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 5: To Fort Dragonia!! |
| Sheep007 05/15/17 6:10:29 PM #80 | If Corrik is Doc that just makes me believe the SK theory even more imo. Of course there's gonna be a lot of protection if there's 2 SKs. Leafeon13N posted... Sheeeeep Whaaaaat --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 5: To Fort Dragonia!! |
| Sheep007 05/15/17 6:04:36 PM #76 | benjamin3740 posted... Sheep007 posted...benjamin3740 posted...Sheep, you never thought for a second on day 1 that Oddity could be scum? Sheep007 posted... Oddity is questioning things and isn't just going along with everyone else's opinions. Scum could easily just repeat views about the millers which have been said countless times already. At least there's some seemingly original thought going on. There's another post that I can't find which had a little more (I think I posted it at least, may not have since I can't see it anywhere). Before he claimed. God would probably be one of my top lynch picks, this doesn't really seem to me like a particularly Town God as he's felt less involved (ah, the hypocrisy... this could also be due to this being more active than the usual games he'd be in) and he's also claimed Vanilla in what is likely to be a more power-heavy setup based on the amount of kills so far at night (we should have a fair bit of power to compensate if there's 5-6 non-Town). However, I'd be fine with lynching any of the Vanilla claims rn except Nana. I think an SK is more likely than Scum randomly deciding to kill each other for no real reason. I guess a second bus driver is possible too, or a PGO or something. IfGodCouldDie posted... So is everyone just going to ignore the train wreck that was bens claim? Train wreck is definitely the right word, but it seems more like Town trying to be clever and failing than Scum trying to legitimately fakeclaim something. He's not under so much pressure that he needed to claim something like that to get him through to tomorrow. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 5: To Fort Dragonia!! |
| Sheep007 05/15/17 5:24:15 PM #44 | benjamin3740 posted... Sheep, you never thought for a second on day 1 that Oddity could be scum? I was fairly sure he was Town pretty much all day. Not 100% obviously, but he was one of my top Town reads along with VI and Nana and I thought he was most likely to be targeted that night. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 5: To Fort Dragonia!! |
| Sheep007 05/15/17 3:49:33 PM #20 | Sorry if I did block you from doing anything VI but you're pretty strongly Town to me and you said you used your power N0 iirc, so I could see no reason why not. Why, as Scum, would I block you over blocking Oddity again, who can basically completely confirm someone as Town or Scum? I said before I used it on Oddity N1 because I wasn't sure any other protection role would think he's Town, I wasn't even sure if there'd be another protection role, plus if I saved him from a kill N1 (which I believe happened barring Scum shooting each other last night or another Bus Driver as I think there's 2 SKs) it may have discouraged someone from killing him last night too, thinking I'd be on him again. I doubt there's 4 on the Mafia team, that'd be stupidly unbalanced considering there's at least 2 third parties as well. Probably another SK too. This setup is already difficult for Town no matter what. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 4 - To get Hydra Humor or not? |
| Sheep007 05/15/17 2:55:57 PM #440 | Nanahara715 posted... I have a bunch of stuff I want to drop but need Sheep in here first. So... --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 4 - To get Hydra Humor or not? |
| Sheep007 05/15/17 2:53:43 PM #438 | benjamin3740 posted... Are people notified when they're jailed? I doubt they're informed specifically that they were jailed because Oddity didn't say anything about a jailer. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 4 - To get Hydra Humor or not? |
| Sheep007 05/15/17 2:44:33 PM #435 | I would apologise for doing fuck all in the day phases this game but I feel that ship has already sailed. I'm Luccia, Jailer. I can lock someone up in my lab, protect them from attack but also stop them from leaving. Yup, visited VI last night, and Oddity the night before because no Scum in their right mind keeps the claimed watcher (or tracker or whatever the hell he's meant to be) alive N1 and I was fairly sure he was Town compared to a lot of other people who weren't. Had no faith in any doctor to keep him alive with the amount of suspicion on him. I was surprised there were so many kills yesterday because I was expecting someone to try and kill the watcher even with the chance of protection, which is why I was wondering where they were coming from (was looking for any sort of miniscule chance of a slip there, although I'll admit it was a shitty attempt). Protected VI because he's obviously Town and the Tracker is kind of useless if he doesn't get to do anything (plus I was hoping me potentially stopping a kill yesterday had discouraged anyone who tried last night from going for Oddity). Anyways, this rambling (blah blah Ben blah blah fluff) has a point. I think there's another SK out there somewhere, which is why PJ died last night but no Town. I also think I probably saved VI from being killed, although there's obviously a chance he dealt out the Scum kill last night and I blocked it, although that's remote. I'm fairly sure there's an SK in the mix somewhere too. Anyways, one more thing. I think someone said Red softclaimed Vig earlier today (I only skimmed so I may be wrong on some things)? Any quote on that? If there's another SK, the softclaimed Vig would probably be my first suspect. Everyone who hasn't claimed yet needs to do so now, and if anyone could grab a claims list that would be great. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 4 - To get Hydra Humor or not? |
| Sheep007 05/13/17 5:44:24 PM #118 | Damn, this feels dead... I know I'm not really doing much to help that either but I honestly don't have much to say which hasn't been said already. I'm sure this will get someone going after me for being lazy but I think voting the claimed 3rd party is the best move right now. Get a potential Scum vote out of the way. ##Vote: Scare --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 3 - Viper Manor: Nikki, Guile, or Pierre? |
| Sheep007 05/12/17 1:14:44 PM #398 | pjbasis posted... Sheep007 posted...Idk how I didn't notice this earlier but where does the third kill come from last night? Corrik is clearly the Scum kill because of the Janitor, Shadow is probably the SK kill as I mentioned above, but how does Scept die? Okay, that makes sense. I know very little about B8 meta aside from like 2 games and a few games with others elsewhere. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 3 - Viper Manor: Nikki, Guile, or Pierre? |
| Sheep007 05/12/17 1:13:30 PM #397 | I'm doing it to try and figure out exactly what is going on at night, Ben. There was a kill and I wasn't sure where it came from. Is Janitor normally a second kill or a modifier here? The one I remember was just a modifier. It's a bit of thinking out loud tbh. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 3 - Viper Manor: Nikki, Guile, or Pierre? |
| Sheep007 05/12/17 1:00:54 PM #391 | But like where would the kill come from before a bus drive? --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 3 - Viper Manor: Nikki, Guile, or Pierre? |
| Sheep007 05/12/17 12:55:54 PM #389 | Idk how I didn't notice this earlier but where does the third kill come from last night? Corrik is clearly the Scum kill because of the Janitor, Shadow is probably the SK kill as I mentioned above, but how does Scept die? --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 3 - Viper Manor: Nikki, Guile, or Pierre? |
| Sheep007 05/12/17 12:53:38 PM #388 | |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 3 - Viper Manor: Nikki, Guile, or Pierre? |
| Sheep007 05/12/17 12:48:55 PM #386 | Terra-enforcer posted... Sheep007 posted...D2 didn't go up til 3AM for me if that's what you're referring to Terra... I had a few posts D1D1 and I posted a few times in the evening of D1D2 too, but that's a fair point, I should have done more at the time. That's my bad. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 3 - Viper Manor: Nikki, Guile, or Pierre? |
| Sheep007 05/12/17 12:34:52 PM #383 | VeryInsane posted... Also Sheep is EU right I'm UK, 5 hours behind EST (I think) but I'll likely only be active in my afternoon/evening and weekends. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 3 - Viper Manor: Nikki, Guile, or Pierre? |
| Sheep007 05/12/17 12:33:39 PM #382 | What's also interesting is the janitoring of Corrik. I thought it would be a pretty common view that Corrik was lying through his teeth about the Miller claim, so that means Scum are either inexperienced enough to kill him anyway, scared of him attacking them, or trying to frame Ulti (although there's also the potential for bus drives and stuff anyway.). Another thing about the night kills, I think Scept knew Shadow, so killing her may have been because of that. SK would normally kill a less prominent player anyway to avoid saves and stuff anyway especially since there was a claimed Watcher about (although them seemingly knowing each other may have played a part in the kill and what I suspect was Shadow bussing Scept). I don't see any other reason for her to have died unless she bussed herself. I also doubt Scept would be targeted for a kill either because several people voiced suspicions about him iirc and he'd be an easier ML than most. This makes me think that Shadow bussed him from a better target. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 3 - Viper Manor: Nikki, Guile, or Pierre? |
| Sheep007 05/12/17 12:25:00 PM #379 | D2 didn't go up til 3AM for me if that's what you're referring to Terra... --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 3 - Viper Manor: Nikki, Guile, or Pierre? |
| Sheep007 05/12/17 12:21:58 PM #376 | I'm looking back through everything now, found a site which I can actually make notes on because I don't know enough of the players and don't have enough time to remember everything. Should hopefully help my play and analysis. Urname based way too much of his play off flavour D1 for my liking just from the first few pages of T1. Put his vote on MZero early based only on that, and jumped back on him late in the day, although one of the other options was himself, so I could forgive him for that. He'd probably be one of my top picks for Scum. Makes me feel a little better about PJ as well, if he's as inexperienced as I presume he is, given he jumped off him at the end of the day, although it may partially have been to save himself. PJ was being unhelpful, not doing much at all, and I thought most of the other lynch candidates (Oddity and MZero at least) were Town, while I had no read on Urname as I barely remembered anything from him. I probably should have read back through the thread but I was pretty tired at the time. Basically, I chose the least bad option. Not great and generally lazy play, I know. I guess I did sort of dip out, this has been a little too fast paced for me so far. Hopefully I can get used to the speed soon. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 3 - Viper Manor: Nikki, Guile, or Pierre? |
| Sheep007 05/12/17 12:01:31 PM #370 | benjamin3740 posted... Dont like Nana and Red taking such firm stances on either side of the game (Nana saying Oddity is the only one we should lynch while Red says Ulti), trying to steer the game really hard that way, and also having little interaction with each other despite their opposing stances. I haven't been around enough to do anything, I read through the thread this morning up to about post 200 but didn't have time to say anything, and I checked the poll just before I left work. I would absolutely have voted Ulti in among the whole Oddity thing. Don't like how adamant Nana was about lynching Oddity, but this absolutely still seems like Town Nana. I would still be somewhat okay with lynching PJ but it's not worth pursuing right now. I accept my vote was bad but I didn't particularly want to lynch MZero and there honestly wasn't anyone who stood out to me as Scum at that point. Oh hey Terra's going for me too. I kind of have an actual job now with normal person hours and shit so expect me to be less active than I used to. I'm not a new player but have been away for a few years. I think I'm pretty damn rusty too. I don't think the best way to start playing again was with a game which spanned one topic in 5 day phases and then another which has been 1 topic per real life day either. Being stuck on mobile is also shit for reading back. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 2 - Where Angels Lose Their Way... |
| Sheep007 05/10/17 6:45:07 PM #301 | PJ has still barely contributed... I wish I could stick around longer but I really should sleep. Bloody timezones. This vote feels far too safe to me, but I guess there's worse things than a safe vote. If he isn't going to help us there's no sense in keeping him alive over anyone else. ##Vote: PJ I'm off for the night now so won't be able to reply to any messages for the rest of the day. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 2 - Where Angels Lose Their Way... |
| Sheep007 05/10/17 6:21:15 PM #273 | The Miller thing again is reminding me of my earlier question. Does anyone have the roles from previous games by this host? It might be able to tell us more about a potential curveball like two Millers. I'm very hesitant to go anywhere near a lynch on any of those three right now since I trust Ulti and Corrik about as far as I can throw them with regards to being honest about roles, although Ulti's claim sounds fairly believable to me. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 2 - Where Angels Lose Their Way... |
| Sheep007 05/10/17 6:08:35 PM #259 | ScareChan posted... currently leaning Town Ulti because I feel scum ulti would have shoved I AM HOST CONFIRMED TOWN down everyones throats Town Ulti shoved it down everyone's throats and got lynched for it last game... --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 2 - Where Angels Lose Their Way... |
| Sheep007 05/10/17 5:55:12 PM #243 | Ouch, no read from everyone. That cuts deep man... Seriously though, I know I've done a bad job so far today. Haven't really got into it and I don't have any real scumreads. My current pick would be PJ for uselessness but I really need to get my arse into gear because even after rereading I don't get much aside from vague gut feelings that God is Scum, and that's mostly due to activity and how little he's trying to take control which is barely applicable as I've not played with him for ages and this is a completely different scenario to the other game in terms of activity and other players... *ahem* --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 2 - Where Angels Lose Their Way... |
| Sheep007 05/10/17 4:40:52 PM #224 | Nanahara715 posted... Was liking Terra until he got defensive against VI, as if VI was THE TOWN PLAYER MAYOR MCCHEESE and was worried everyone will follow him. Still like him better than some others. I disagree about post 202 because, although I'd rather have more detailed analysis on fewer players, it's nice to know what one player is thinking about everyone. Can help show contradictions later on too. Also, wouldn't it be better for Scum to attempt to target those who aren't their teammates, rather than feign indifference to them all? Now, about this post. That last sentence really rubs me the wrong way... Why specifically Oddity? It seems like you're trying to reinforce a point which is almost completely unaffected by the post in question. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 2 - Where Angels Lose Their Way... |
| Sheep007 05/10/17 2:17:20 PM #164 | Leafeon13N posted... Look at his sig, sheep. I have them turned off cause they annoy me... VeryInsane posted... Sheep007 posted...Who is RIPJimmy? Have I just not been paying attention or is he an alt or something? I posted something in the other topic since for some reason I didn't realise this was up. I would c/p but my phone will probably bugger about. Basically people seeing Nana and Corrik as more scummy is quite reasonable and makes me think they're Town, especially Oddity on Nana because it's easy to join the circlejerk as Scum whereas saying something people disagree with is far more likely to mean they get drawn out. For you, it's because you're the most active player. I think I've played with you before (I definitely recognize the username) and I don't remember you being terribly active, so the amount you're adding here is pretty positive. Nana is playing exactly like Town Nana, and Scum Nana isn't even comparable. Oddity is questioning things and isn't just going along with everyone else's opinions. Scum could easily just repeat views about the millers which have been said countless times already. At least there's some seemingly original thought going on. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 2 - Where Angels Lose Their Way... |
| Sheep007 05/10/17 12:25:03 PM #134 | Who is RIPJimmy? Have I just not been paying attention or is he an alt or something? I posted something in the other topic since for some reason I didn't realise this was up. I would c/p but my phone will probably bugger about. Basically people seeing Nana and Corrik as more scummy is quite reasonable and makes me think they're Town, especially Oddity on Nana because it's easy to join the circlejerk as Scum whereas saying something people disagree with is far more likely to mean they get drawn out. I'm really not sure about the Oddity lynch. I've got a good feeling about him, but the same goes for VI and Nana. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 1 - Good Morning, Serge! |
| Sheep007 05/10/17 11:36:53 AM #436 | MZero11 posted... IfGodCouldDie posted...whatisurnameplz posted...I didn't get that much sleep last night so I'm gonna go to bed now. Right now corrik is looking more and more scummy to me. I really don't understand why he's so adamant in VI by scum. I don't like how IGCD just posts one liners and votes while doing nothing substantial, like he's afraid he might say something that'll make him look scummy. Glad that Oddity is catching up. Shadow and VI both seem pretty town to me at the moment, probably the only ones I can definitely say that about. Ulti's looking less and less town after everyone's been pointing out his bad comments. I'll be back tomorrow, hopefully they more inactive people will be able to discuss then. Good night. Idk if anyone does that but it's surpisingly apt. It's also funny that several people have brought up Nana or Corrik being Scum with no prior knowledge on their playstyles. I think that Nana is Town at least, although I'm less sure on Corrik, but I know how both of them play. Plus points to those calling them out to some extent as they aren't joining the circlejerk which is easy to do as Scum. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 1 - Good Morning, Serge! |
| Sheep007 05/09/17 5:52:30 PM #263 | Shadow_Goer16 posted... What are the chances of 3rd party fool being in the game? One the Miller claims could be 3rd party probably 3rd party fool/miller...? I somehow doubt it. I don't think bastard games without prior warning are particularly common. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 1 - Good Morning, Serge! |
| Sheep007 05/09/17 4:30:50 PM #220 | VeryInsane posted... Hey Nana since you are CE and most likely Town what do you think of I know I'm not Nana but I only realised Terra was in this game cause his name is highlighted for me. He's done less than I remember, but this is more active than our usual games and I've also not played with him for a long time. Still not been up for 24 hours yet either so I'm sure we'll see more. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 1 - Good Morning, Serge! |
| Sheep007 05/09/17 4:26:31 PM #217 | VeryInsane posted... Nana is Town Reasons or just gut? I don't disagree with you, at least with Nana. He's exactly as I remember him as Town (bullish is perhaps the word I would use), although he may have improved his Scum game recently (yes I know half my quotes are from him but he's probably the player here I know best, along with Terra. I'd like to get a firm read on at least one of them so I know where I'm standing and potentially bounce ideas off him). I get a good gut feel from Sceptile too. Pretty neutral on Ben. Nanahara715 posted...
I agree it should have been a PM, but hosts should say this regardless. I think you're going a bit deep in the whole "scum gambit" bit though. Nanahara715 posted... Rather, your second post implies you hadn't read the game at the time of you right first post. More fun with maths ...I think you're just reading a bit deep again and it's a joke. You know, like the Miller claim 5 minutes before. Not honest, sure, but I wouldn't take it seriously. I don't like it, but it doesn't mean he's Scum, like all the weird things God and Corrik have done before. I agree with your later post saying he shouldn't be allowed to skate by, however. He's more arguing about why he shouldn't be lynched for doing nothing than actually attempting to contribute to scumhunting as well. I mean, why join if you aren't trying? --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 1 - Good Morning, Serge! |
| Sheep007 05/09/17 4:03:20 PM #215 | Leafeon13N posted... The role/flavor meta here is too deep to be useful. Yeah, it feels like the only thing some people talk about and it's hardly a riveting way to draw everyone into the game. Like I mentioned before, a lot of good hosts try and make it uncertain (hence why I asked for anything about this host's previous games) --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 1 - Good Morning, Serge! |
| Sheep007 05/09/17 3:59:30 PM #214 | benjamin3740 posted... (I feel so useless in games when i dont know the flavor -.-;;) Pretty sure that meta isn't the only way to scumhunt bud... Oh hey, Corrik exists and claimed a 4th miller which I missed on my first skim through. Possibly because my brain instantly disregards any claim from him with no proof. Oddity posted... I caught up. Not really willing to sort out the 3 miller claims right now. I have to go to work like 5 mins ago. I kind of want to lynch VI for trying to make this a Corrik/Ulti day. Interesting point. I read VI's post again and "Either you or Corrik have to go" looks to me like trying to play it up. I don't know much about the internal politics of B8 Mafia and most of the player's history, so I'm a little wary of putting too much on this as it's quite circumstantial. However, the counterpoints to this from VI and Ben are both interesting and it seems more like a "how to win" debate than "how to lynch Scum". Nanahara715 posted... I mean, just random numbers tells us that there's a 58% chance at least one of Ulti & Corrik are mafia, 42% that they are both town, and an 9% chance they are both mafia. I forgot that Nana loves statistics a little too much... The somewhat misleading bit at the bottom is new though. --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Topic 1 - Good Morning, Serge! |
| Sheep007 05/09/17 3:38:59 PM #211 | benjamin3740 posted... whatisurnameplz posted...I'm pretty well knowledged, I'm sure a few others are as well. If you have any questions we can answer them. I'm Town Mill... Never mind, reading further forward I think that joke died quite quickly... I sadly know nothing about the flavour so I'll be no use in that regard. I've skimmed through the topic already and am now going through some of my thoughts. I'll likely repeat some things that have already been said but please bear with. UltimaterializerX posted... MZero11 posted...I'm Glenn, Miller Oh, so this looks fun already. Quick counterclaim, possibly to catch him off guard from Ulti? How much does Ulti know about the flavour to allow him to claim this? It's unlikely that Ulti is fakeclaiming his character at least, and if it works with the flavour as is mentioned by some people in later posts, it'd be even more unlikely imo. I'm definitely more inclined to believe Ulti is Town based on these interactions, while MZero doesn't exactly look great. I don't believe PJ's Miller claim at all for some reason though... I'd also suggest not basing on votes on which character seems to be "more appropriate" for the role. A lot of good hosts throw in red herrings and put roles on the safelist which may match more than the flavour for an actual role. Any archives of any games the host has previously put on? --- |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Sign Up Topic |
| Sheep007 05/08/17 4:42:04 PM #94 | |
| Topic | Chrono Cross Mafia Sign Up Topic |
| Sheep007 05/05/17 6:56:36 PM #57 | I don't recognize most of the roster but I'm in. Hopefully there's a bit of spark in this one. --- |
| Board List | Page List: 1 |